Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Rate the NFCS quarterbacks.

76 posts in this topic

Posted

Olsen is a better player today than tony is today.

Id take smith over white today

So really its only juilo we are missing which is huge but we also have more talented runners.

Its really time for Cam to put it all together, no more excuses, its time to win.

Greg Olsen-69 Rec 843yds 5td

TG-93rec 930yds 8td

SS-73rec 1174yds 4td

RW-92rec 1351yds 7td

Yea it's more than just Julio but keep telling yourself that I won't even compare his numbers to Lafell.

2 people like this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

I don't think any of those QBs could do what Cam did at Auburn in 2010(I know, this is the NFL)

Cam is still top 50 player on a 'sophomore slump' on a losing team. 

 

The better question is which QB is harder to defend. Since the Giants defense stated after going against RG3 the prior week facing Brees is much easier(Saints got manhandled), being that Cam and RG3 have similar skill set, I would say Cam is harder to defend in the division.

 

By deductive reasoning Cam is the better QB. Until Cam crap his pants on a team with a good OL, WRs, etc. he'll always get my vote.

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

I agree that Cam has more talent than Ryan and will be better, but Ryan is more of a closer now. Think about all the close games last year that Atlanta pulled out last year at the last minute.

That is true but it has absolutely nothing to do with Ryan being the better QB. Cam tried to close games and the D or ST would give it away.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

Greg Olsen-69 Rec 843yds 5td

TG-93rec 930yds 8td

SS-73rec 1174yds 4td

RW-92rec 1351yds 7td

Yea it's more than just Julio but keep telling yourself that I won't even compare his numbers to Lafell.

So youd rather have gonzalez instead of olsen and white instead of smith?

Ask your self what smitty would have done lined up alongside julio jones and what olsen would have done with ryan who is a more accurate short passer than Cam. You cant compare numbers you have to look at the players.

fitz is a key example of this.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

1. Brees

2. Ryan

3. Cam

4. Freeman

 

I love Cam as much as anyone on here but until he gets a winning season under his belt and makes the playoffs we can't make a case for him being better than Drew Brees or Matt Ryan.

you are a very wise man.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

So youd rather have gonzalez instead of olsen and white instead of smith?

Ask your self what smitty would have done lined up alongside julio jones and what olsen would have done with ryan who is a more accurate short passer than Cam. You cant compare numbers you have to look at the players.

fitz is a key example of this.

Fitz played with the worst starting qbs in nfl history not the same.

To answer your question yes I would take Julio over Steve Smith today. If we are talking Steve smith in his prime its not even close. What people don't want to admit about Smityy is that he has become an inconsistent player and will drop some catchable balls.

Also I would take Tony G over Olsen today and its not close

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

Number one im not debating jones and smith. Number two if youd rather have gonzo (who promised retirement all year last year) over olsen you are insane. Gonzo is another year older and another step slower.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

People do not understand how very very small of a talent difference there is from team to team in the nfl. qbs are the main seperators. You either have one or you dont. Cam is the only extremely talented qb in this league who has not been to the playoffs. Its put up or shut up time.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

People do not understand how very very small of a talent difference there is from team to team in the nfl. qbs are the main seperators. You either have one or you dont. Cam is the only extremely talented qb in this league who has not been to the playoffs. Its put up or shut up time.

You don't have to debate. Men lie, women lie, numbers don't. Matt Ryan doesn't have the best two seasons of a Qb in nfl history, Cam Newton Does. If you don't think he has vastly more weapons than Cam then you need to lay off the prescriptions.

This is the ultimate team sport it's not put up or shut up for any one player because he's been putting up he doesn't have the talent around him period.

1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

Not the best two year stretch ever, the best two years to start a career. Football is the ultimate team sport that is made by ONE player. Its time to win. Not to make excuses when we lose because we lack talent. Thats garbage.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

Football is the ultimate team sport that is made by ONE player.

 

Hmmmm.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted

Now:

Brees

Ryan

Cam

Freeman

Future:

Cam

Freeman

Brees

Ryan

If I gotta win a game today, I'm taking Brees.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites