Mr. Scot

There are very few quarterbacks I would be comfortable ascribing that ability to. The vast majority require a strong team and organization around them to succeed. Bryce clearly isn't one of those guys, and he's never going to be one of those guys, but you don't absolutely have to have one of those guys if you have the right team building. I don't really think I have to say whether or not we have that here

Like Samir Suleiman did?

It's year 8 of Tepper. Outside of him, coaches, GMs and various others have changed multiple times and some haven't been here long enough to make any truly significant impact (Tilis being a prime example but you could argue for others)

Front office chooses the scouting department. For my part, I wasn't a fan of Cole Spencer. We only parted ways with him this year and I'm hoping that proves to be a positive in the future.

Not sure about reporters, but fans do that all the time. Hell, if you were to ask some people on here, Cam Newton never had a single bad game in his entire career. Regardless of whether it's Young, Newton, Delhomme, Clausen, Teddy Bridgewater or even Matt Moore, It's never "everybody else's fault" anymore than it's ever all one person's fault. Young's performance this past Sunday was not good enough, but he had plenty of help.

Does that include firing Brandt Tilis? (he just got here)

He has had access to exactly such a person (or people) for several years now, but whether he has any inclination to do such a thing is unknown.

With some people you can at least identify a trend in their mistakes: always too cautious, too reckless, too generous, too stingy, overthinking, impulsive, etc. Sadly, Tepper is one of those people who can make mistakes in every possible manner. (omni-incompetent...or perhaps omnincompetent, if you want to put a word to it) He needs, as he has always needed, someone who actually has a clue making all his decisions for him. There were hints that was going to be Dan Morgan's role now, but is Morgan the right choice for the job? The problem with finding somebody to make good decisions for somebody who consistently makes terrible decisions is that it's still the bad decision maker's decision who he picks to make the good decisions...unless he picks someone else to make that decision, but even then will he make a good decision as to who decides who... Ya know what? I'm tired My Answer: I don't know. At this point I'm.probably just praying for a miracle.

This is where I'm at. He's shown that he can be good. He's also shown he can be very...not good (he's kinda like Revelation 3:15 at this point) Bottom Line: Unless he can be consistently good for more than just the back half of a wasted season, it's not gonna matter.

Well for one, what other realistic choice is there? Barring a season ending injury, Bryce is the guy for this year. Next year all options are open, but there aren't any other real world solutions for the 2025 season.

This was as complete a team loss as you could want. Special Teams weren't especially bad but they weren't really "special" either.

One of the things that makes offensive coaches like Reid and McDaniels good Is that they anticipate defensive adjustments to their attack and plan for them. I wouldn't bet on our braintrust being at that level of thinking just yet

His coaching staff? If not full id say 90-95%. Mind you, if there is interference, it might not necessarily be coming from Tepper.

That was Jerry Jones post Bill Parcells. I'd like to hope he's not that bad but...

Edit: Changed my mind. This conversation is too silly to be part of.

See above. I've said for a while that Tepper basically needs a "king of football" to run the organization while he does nothing but sit back and write checks. Maybe Morgan has that role now, but that's not enough if Morgan isn't up to the task. You need the right structure AND the right people. If you only have one or the other, it's still not good enough.

Possible, but unknown. Honestly, we're still basically just one season removed from him being into everything so it's probably too soon to expect massive turnarounds. All that said, there's no guarantee Morgan is the right guy to lead the franchise. And if he isn't, hands on or hands off doesn't matter.

I'm not sure anyone knows those dynamics right now. Tepper has assured everyone that he's "hands off" now. I tend to believe, BUT that doesn't guarantee everything is okay.

Pacing an NFL team is an extremely difficult thing to do. Tom Coughlin used to pistol whip his guys in training camp. The result was that they nearly always started off hot, but also regularly faded down the stretch. Other coaches would go easy in the offseason and thus produce teams that looked like sh-t early but improved down the stretch. Problem being unfortunately that by the time they looked good, they were already in too big hole to dig out of. Finding that balance is EXTREMELY difficult. Plenty of coaches never do

We hired Canales primarily because of his connection with Dan Morgan. Secondarily because not too many genuinely good candidates want to work for David Tepper. Could he still turn out to be good? Yes, but he dug himself a hole with this start. (that last sentence applies equally to Bryce Young)

Practical Answer: Canales might be another Ron Rivera type that's either too nice or too slow to pull the trigger on firings. I get being patient, and I get wanting to give guys a chance, but when somebody does something HISTORICALLY bad, you just can't afford those things.

I've said that for every game one I've seen for every team for the past fifty years.

The only thing Hooker is lighting a fire to these days is all the hype he had coming out of college.

End of last season he looked great. Today? Not so much. I need to see better, and I need to see CONSISTENTLY better to keep him, but one week where a load of people around him looked bad isn't enough.

He should have fired Evero