
Mr. Scot
HUDDLER-
Posts
139,395 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Huddle Wiki
Forums
Gallery
Everything posted by Mr. Scot
-
Pretty sure he'd have to be external to do that.
-
Sure, dude
-
Mentions that Johnson could bring the Lions OL coach Hank Farley along as an OC.
-
Evero gets a second interview...
-
On the actual topic...
-
You claim I'm misquoting something, only to turn around and completely mischaracterize what I've said Can you actually quote where I've said analytics shouldn't be used at all? Hint: I haven't. What I did say was in response to the suggestion that if we'd engaged in analytics we might not have messed up on Young and others, etc. Hence, why I pointed out to our sadly mistaken friend that we did.
-
NFL Playoffs Divisional Round - Games Thread
Mr. Scot replied to Bear Hands's topic in Carolina Panthers
Meanwhile... -
NFL Playoffs Divisional Round - Games Thread
Mr. Scot replied to Bear Hands's topic in Carolina Panthers
If the hype videos are any indication... -
Oh, I'm pretty comfortable with the way this "pointless" discussion is going You've made clear you don't understand basic differences or definitions (historical data? yeah, sure). Hell, your last response was basically you signing on to something I'd already explained was foolish. You don't get it. I doubt you're going to, but I expect you'll keep trying just so you can tell yourself you've stood up to me. But hey, do you
-
Not sure it's gonna be today because of the games. Tomorrow morning, maybe...
-
Keep trying, dude
-
Meanwhile...
-
Baseball. And frankly, that's a sport where it makes more sense. It's more individual in nature and stat driven in results. Football is far more physical in nature and requires heavy teamwork and chemistry on both sides of the ball. Again, I know people want it to be some kind of magic bullet, but it just isn't.
-
Scouting that included...wait for it, analytics Reality is that a lot of football analytics is basically just an attempt to quantify things that are already scouted, as if judging an offensive lineman's knee bend using a caliper somehow makes it more reliable than just using your eyes. Hint: It doesn't. I know there are people who think analytics is somehow going to make scouting foolproof. It's not. Nor will anything else. It's always going to be an inexact science that some people will be better at than others. Acting like it's some magic wand is silly.
-
Dude, you don't even know the difference between analytics and measurables. Tepper is a huge analytics fan. The Panthers have an analytics department and have incorporated it into their scouting. It's not some missing element like you want to believe. Keep trying if you want, but oy...
-
It's a possibility.
-
The problem over the past few years was poor decision making. Does relying on analytics fix that though? No. Tepper is already heavily engaged in analytics as part of what we do. We're not missing that element. What we're missing is better personnel evaluation.
-
First and only at the moment...
-
It's definitely possible. The decision could already be made but the NFL hates when non-playoff team announcements take attention away from the playoffs themselves.
-
Callahan has been on the head coaching radar for a while now. Of the GM list, Halaby is the one I'd absolutely not want. The Athletic story about him being part of the toxic atmosphere that helped force Doug Pederson out in Philly reads like an even worse version of the "Hunger Games" story from the Panthers this year. Brandon Brown would be my favorite at the moment, but I'd hire Dan Morgan before I'd want Halaby.
-
No longer a guess now... He's the only name I've seen confirmed so far though I imagine we could get more news soon.