
Mr. Scot
HUDDLER-
Posts
139,937 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Huddle Wiki
Forums
Gallery
Everything posted by Mr. Scot
-
Who thinks Wilks and PJ are still the answers?
Mr. Scot replied to mc52beast's topic in Carolina Panthers
We've said it before, but being an interim coach is a seriously tough path. You're coaching players you didn't choose with a staff you didn't hire to run systems you didn't create. It's a nearly impossible task. As far as Wilks, I believe there are plenty of people who would have liked to see him succeed, but I don't think too many people were predicting it. -
How would we know if he did? Airing those things out publicly would be unprofessional. There's only one guy who would be in a position to know these things. That guy fired Rhule but is keeping Fitterer.
-
Did he have the power to overrule him? If he didn't, what else would you suggest he should have done?
-
Or maybe I can just read Joe Person and Charles Robinson's reports or for that matter Matt Rhule's own words. I realize you don't think those things carry as much weight as your opinion but I feel kinda differently.
-
Go back and read Person's story from The Athletic.
-
I don’t buy the notion that players don’t want to tank..
Mr. Scot replied to UpstatePantherfan's topic in Carolina Panthers
A player who willingly participated in a tank would be cutting his own throat. -
Per Joe Person, he only "signed off" on acquiring Darnold (Mayfield too). Fitterer believes in drafting quarterbacks.
-
It was reported there was a conversation between Joe Schoen and Dan Morgan before the picks were made. Make of that what you will...
-
Holcomb wasn't the linebackers coach. That's Mike Siravo (a Rhule guy). Holcomb was the LB coach when we had Kuechly and Davis.
-
Yes, based on recommendations from the scouting staff, GM and assistant GM. Rhule himself said he wasn't capable of doing the legwork that led up to the draft. That's why he didn't want an analytics based GM. (it's one of the few good things he did)
-
Cooper was basically Rhule's right hand man. As was said before, I'm surprised he wasn't gone already.
-
Pretty difficult to mess up on something you were never doing.
-
You think he personally scouted all our draft prospects?
-
Rhule had final say, but didn't do any of the draft scouting or evaluation. That was the scouting department under Fitterer. The only real scouting Rhule did was checking whether they played for him at Temple or Baylor.
- 109 replies
-
- 15
-
-
-
Predict the next Panthers win ITT
Mr. Scot replied to Sean Payton's Vicodin's topic in Carolina Panthers
Remaining Schedule: Falcons @Ravens Broncos BYE @Seahawks Steelers Lions @Buccaneers @Saints -
worst half in panther football history?
Mr. Scot replied to DJ feed me moore's topic in Carolina Panthers
I honestly don't remember much outside of Fasani having a zero rating. -
worst half in panther football history?
Mr. Scot replied to DJ feed me moore's topic in Carolina Panthers
Fasani game? -
Always fun watching Brady get pissed off...
-
Pie to those on this board… you’re here when it’s ROCK BOTTOM
Mr. Scot replied to TheBigKat's topic in Carolina Panthers
Survived Marty Hurney... Survived Matt Rhule... Hoping the team's next hire isn't someone I need to survive- 40 replies
-
- 13
-
-
-
Who thinks Wilks and PJ are still the answers?
Mr. Scot replied to mc52beast's topic in Carolina Panthers
Were there people who actually thought this? -
Confirmed: Al Holcomb is not good at his job
Mr. Scot replied to Proudiddy's topic in Carolina Panthers
Not Campen or Tabor...