Tell me if you think this trade is even

[Killa Cam 69]

Eziquel Elliot cam newton and mike Evans for McCaffrey Jon brown and Kerryon Jonson... 

[KSpan]

Not particularly, no.

[Killa Cam 69]

Yeah I couldn’t wrap my head around it the guy that got cam Evans and Elliot is in fourth the go who got shafted is in ninth in a 12 man league.. I’m all for trades and of coarse they will never be perfect but I couldn’t believe it went through no problem 

[KSpan]

9 hours ago, Killa Cam 69 said:

Yeah I couldn’t wrap my head around it the guy that got cam Evans and Elliot is in fourth the go who got shafted is in ninth in a 12 man league.. I’m all for trades and of coarse they will never be perfect but I couldn’t believe it went through no problem 

It's a trade that doesn't look very smart but if there isn't any collusion, no reason to cancel it IMO.

[Varking]

On 10/31/2018 at 4:59 PM, Killa Cam 69 said:

Eziquel Elliot cam newton and mike Evans for McCaffrey Jon brown and Kerryon Jonson... 

Maybe it depends on scoring format but in my league Cam is the #4 QB and only 4 points behind Luck for #3 and Luck is on a Bye so Cam Newton will pass him. Zeke is RB#9 in my league. McCaffrey is RB#10, only .5 points behind Zeke. Kerryon Johnson is RB#27. Mike Evans is WR#10. Brown is WR#16. 

So one way to view the trade is:

Player A is giving up QB3, RB9 and WR10

Player B is giving up RB10, RB27 and WR16. 

A second way"

Player A is losing 17.5 points for Evans to Brown. 

Player A is losing .5 points for Zeke to McCaffery

Player A is losing 89.5 points for Cam to Johnson. 

Not sure what the format is in your league but unless player A has Mahomes or Ryan it seems like a stupid trade just to get rid of Cam in this. Zeke and CMC are a wash. Evans to brown is a massive downgrade as well. At no point is this dude winning and I would start to suspect collusion if this is a pay league.