Terry Bradshaw ranked Dalton ahead of Cam...

[GritsRgreat]

The offense would look completely different and most likely worse because Dalton lacks Newton's elite arm strength and elite running ability.

IDK i think they would run the ball a lot more. Dalton doesn't have a problem running Cinci's offense and they have a lot less weapons.

[Swarly]

IDK i think they would run the ball a lot more. Dalton doesn't have a problem running Cinci's offense and they have a lot less weapons.

they have good weapons though, don't act like the Panthers are leaps and bounds better

solid o-line, pretty damn good TE(no worse than either of ours), a future super star receiver(he's no Steve Smith but not many are), and their #2/#3 WR's aren't that much better(or worse) than ours.

honestly I'd say it's pretty damn close to a draw in supporting casts. if we used our RB's more maybe it'd be better but we don't(something I'd like to change....)

im not going to let you bitches troll me so I won't comment on the topic of this thread, just making an objective observation

[ItsPantone278]

Dalton: Connecting on all the throws you have to make and taking care of the football. Doing the things you have to do to win games consistently. Having a great season and has been very impressive as a rookie. Cincinnati has been building up that defense and getting depth and talent on the o line, and now they've plugged in their skill players and they are a very good young team.

Cam: Wow. Thats really all you can say if you've watched him play. He makes plays that just make your eyes pop on a regular basis. Statistically, he already holds several NFL records, and is on pace to shatter a few more in his rookie season. Unfortunately he has yet to prove that he can make all the plays that win you football games as consistently. Unlike Dalton, Cam comes to a team loaded with talented personnel but for a completely different offensive scheme. He does not enjoy half the defensive protection as Dalton does, as the Panthers LB depth has been completely decimated in a year that we had to go plan b at DT.

Dalton looks like a really solid QB that is having a great season. I don't think he's shown anything particularly special other than his surprisingly solid rookie performance to date. Guys like him have great seasons some years, sometimes mediocre. I'd say he may peak out over that Matt Ryan tier...

Cam looks like a future hall of famer that can take over games similar to the way Peyton Manning takes over games, but in a completely different way. Go with Cam. Its unbelievable when you really think about the reality of having this guy be a part of this franchise. He can take us to the very top.

[antame]

Exactly. Again, Dalton's looked slightly better so far. Would rather we have Cam.

[bigcatdaddy]

Exactly. Again, Dalton's looked slightly better so far. Would rather we have Cam.

Dalton has not looked better, Cam's stats are a lot better in every category.

[Pox 08]

The way Dalton can turn a ball over twice, throw for under 200 yards............and know that he has a defense that can bail him out, and still win a game by double digits.. He's definitely a stud, and obviously the main reason the Bengals win their games. He's not this years equivalent of a weaker armed Mark Sanchez at all.