Should I make this trade?

[mwa78]

Here is my team :

Vick/Schaub

Calvin Johnson/Miles Austin/M. Colston

Ray Rice/L McCoy/ Beanie Wells/Felix Jones

Here is what I have been offered:

Forte, DeSean Jackson, Percy Harvin

for

Vick, Colston, Wells

I think I could get him to switch change Harvin to Matt Ryan for the trade, that way I would have 2nd QB. What do you think?

[mwa78]

FWIW:

we start 1 QB, 2 RB, 2 WR, 1 Flex(RB or WR)

[panthermonium]

Is it a ppr league?

Personally I wouldnt do it. Harvin and Jackson have been underwhelming at best. Forte is an absolute monster though especially in ppr leagues. Still, I don't like the trade. You are strong at rb with mccoy and rice.

[panthermonium]

Although the more I look at it you do have megatron and Austin is a solid #2. Throw forte into the flex and your team looks strong. FWIW I value rb WAY more than any other position esp if you are in a ppr league. I always thought you could roll with a serviceable qb and still be ok. I got eli late in one league and he's been just fine.

Fug it. Do it.

[mwa78]

Yes...ppr league

[Dpantherman]

If you can talk him out of giving up Vick, id bite. Id offer him Shaub first. Of course there are injury concerns, but you might be able to pick up a decent backup if necessary

[mr beauxjangles]

Holy hell, how many teams are in your league? 4? Why would you change a monster team like that?

You say you don't start a TE, which is weird, so I can't speak to that. But looking at your roster the only spot I'd want to improve is QB. I'd try to package Vick and another potential starter (Wells, Austin) for a top 4 QB and bench player.

I wouldn't trade Colston. You stuck through his early season absence, so don't trade him now when he's putting up great numbers. And DeSean Jackson has much less value in a PPR league.

[mwa78]

10 man PPR league....

I don't think I am going to do it...it is enticing to have McCoy, Rice, and Forte though....

[mr beauxjangles]

10 man PPR league....

I don't think I am going to do it...it is enticing to have McCoy, Rice, and Forte though....

how did you manage to pull vick, mccoy, rice, and megatron in a 10 team ppr league? seriously. are you playing with a bunch of idiots?