Now we are making progress! (Dead serious)

[Gin and Juice]

no I dont want a fan as a GM. Making Fantasy League trades etc. I want someone that knows how to be a gm, knows how to build a winning football team, knows how to evaluate talent, and knows how to manage cap figures as to not handcuff the team in the future. Beane, lacks the experience necessary.

Your logic eliminates Marc Ross! Who do you want?

[DaCityKats]

Your logic eliminates Marc Ross! Who do you want?

and how? Ross is the director of scouting and has been a scout.

[Mr. Scot]

If you go way back, you might remember that the word on what the Panthers wanted was someone who was "an up and coming GM" (i.e. not a retread) and someone with a "strong scouting background".

And if you want confirmation of that, just look at the current interview list:

Lake Dawson - 12 years scouting experience

George Paton - 16 years scouting experience

Marc Ross - 16 years scouting experience

Dave Gettleman - 25 years scouting experience

Brandon Beane's scouting experience? He watched a bowl game a couple of weeks ago.

[bleys]

If you go way back, you might remember that the word on what the Panthers wanted was someone who was "an up and coming GM" (i.e. not a retread) and someone with a "strong scouting background".

And if you want confirmation of that, just look at the current interview list:

Lake Dawson - 12 years scouting experience

George Paton - 16 years scouting experience

Marc Ross - 16 years scouting experience

Dave Gettleman - 25 years scouting experience

Brandon Beane's scouting experience? He watched a bowl game a couple of weeks ago.

pwned...

[Gin and Juice]

He said he wanted someone that knows how to be a GM, Ross has never been one! He had a multitude of requirements that eliminates pretty much everyone! Trying to see who he had in mind to fill his requirements.

Don't get me wrong, not saying I want Beane as our GM, but I am unimpressed with the Ross resume to the point I feel like, "Hey, let the guy that really wants to do it have a shot!"

[Mr. Scot]

He said he wanted someone that knows how to be a GM, Ross has never been one! He had a multitude of requirements that eliminates pretty much everyone! Trying to see who he had in mind to fill his requirements.

Don't get me wrong, not saying I want Beane as our GM, but I am unimpressed with the Ross resume to the point I feel like, "Hey, let the guy that really wants to do it have a shot!"

Actually, he said he wanted someone who has "never been one".