Replace Cam with any other playoff QB - Do we win 12 games?

[KendrickPanther]

Yeah I don't really know where this thread is headed. It's really getting exhausting. All the arguments about Cam vs. all the other QBs in the league. I'm not worried about what happens in Indianapolis or Denver. I just want Cam to be the best QB possible in Charlotte.

[Car123]

Andrew luck hardly has talent around him does he? Wayne was out most of the season so he had Hilton and fleener that's equates to smitty and olsen, still has better record than cam first two seasons. Not bashing cam but just saying luck has impressed me more than any other qb of late

AFC South is horrible though. The NFC South is a lot tougher.

[footballisasport]

Peyton Manning played behind some horrendous offensive lines in Indy with no run game to speak of and won 12 games consistently.........

If I am not mistaken, it took four seasons for Peyton to get the Colts to the play offs and they were a mych better team than the Panthers by then.

[ajax4132]

If I am not mistaken, it took four seasons for Peyton to get the Colts to the play offs and they were a mych better team than the Panthers by then.

 

They had Edgerrin James and Marvin Harrison, two future HOFs

 

They were very balanced offensively

[footballisasport]

If it were not for Cams legs, our win total would have suffered greatly.

 

He can throw the ball through a brick wall, but his consistency and touch are still works in progress, along with a couple intangables.  He made great strides this season however

 

His stats very similar to last season. Maybe Cam's throwing and whatever "intangibles" you're talking about isn't the problem. 

 

When a QB knows he doesn't have consistent Receivers around him he's left to force the issues. Forced issues caused much mistakes in a QB world. There is a reason why those in the media go out of their way to say their chosen QBs like Luck, doesn't have any real weapons around him. Translation...He's good but he needs harder working players around him to help him look great. Why should Cam be treated any differently?

[fjblair]

These hypothetical scenarios are irrelevant. We have who we have, and I am fine with it. Just keep putting talent around him.

 

No offense to the OP but this is a stupid brain dead thread. I mean you can what if with coaches and players all day but it's impossible and unproductive to say what would happen. Who knows? Who cares?

[jptaylor84]

What were the comparisons in attempts this year to last years offense? I know we went more balanced and run on offense but I'd be interested to see how much he didn't throw the ball compared to last year

[Panther_Brotherhood]

Guys, I love Cam to death, but hes benefiting from an amazing defense 

[carolina-chuck]

Manning and Brady, yup.

 

Anyone else, nope.

[carolina-chuck]

Replace LaFail and Dwill with any other playoff WR and RB - Do we win 12 games?

 

HELL FU(KN YUP!

[General_Purr]

Cam yes

Brady yes

Manning yes

Russell Yes

 

Cam is on a good list no doubt. He stepped up this year. Love watching that dude play

[frash.exe]

Manning would make LaFell a 700 yard receiver

[PantherDynasty]

Why do you guys put Wilson in a class with Cam? I know he has overachieved and his story is nice and he seems like a good player and all, but dude is an average at best QB. He hasn't proven anything and they only win due to having Beast Mode and a nasty defense. The idea that he was long considered #2 in the MVP race wasn't laughable but downright embarassing to the sport. To answer OP's question, Manning, Brady, and Rodgers could. Nobody else

[Evengelion]

Peyton Manning played behind some horrendous offensive lines in Indy with no run game to speak of and won 12 games consistently.........

12 games in the AFC South(jacksonville, Titans, & Texans). That's why they keep getting bounce out of the playoffs almost every year and only won 1 superbowl. Edgering James was a great running back.