carpanfan96

How bad are you going to loose your poo when he gets interviewed and hired?

Who called neutral sites and coin flips?

He's doing what Tepper wants, Tepper wants to win now. It's why they were in on Stafford and in on Watson. For an NFL GM, you've got to balance what your owner wants with the future. If a trade has two or more teams involved, it does work in reverse. Win now has to be balanced somewhat with your teams future. The Rams essentially went all in last season, the 49ers have done so this season.

Same reason that it usually happens, the 49ers and bears didn't want to give up a 2nd in that draft. Most teams don't want to trade away a ton of picks in one draft, so they spread it out. I went after the credibility of pff first before posting that. Lmfao I brought up the Panthers superbowl oline as an example as well. To continue that example, Mike Remmers for had a 66 grade and had 11 penalties and gave up 6 sacks. That oline was pretty bad in pass coverage

Yea I can't see any way he stays with the lvl 1 against him.

He's got a level 1 infraction directly against him. 4 level 2 and God knows what else they have on Michigan. He's gone, imo.

I don't think they grade line play well, Burns is 12th in defensive stops this season. The Panthers also have a much better run block win rate then they do pass run win rate among defensive line advanced stats. Take that for what ever it's worth to you but I honestly don't think PFF knows every teams playbooks or what each player is responsible for every single down. Do they know how to grade power run and which gap the RB is designed to go to? Do they know which blocker is responsible for which defender based on the call and who the QB calls as mike? Do they know what rush defense responsibilities a wide 9 tech has vs the LB on that side of the field compared to that same play call with the DE at say 6 or 7? I honestly don't think they do. :shrugs: I lost faith when they rated the 2015 Panthers oline top 3.

Teams generally move when they meet a combination of factors. Value at pick vs value at pick they are moving to combined with the value of the other picks in the trade. You'll see two bad teams make massive trades and you'll see good teams make those trades as well. 49ers vs bears moving up for QB's. Ones a poorly run team and the other isn't. There's a combination of factors involved like how many players have first round grades for a team and if they move back is the value there for them and their board. Hope all that makes sense, it's late and work was stupid today.

I think they suck at line play grading, but even still... They've had him ranked in the top 10 among edge rushers. https://www.pff.com/news/nfl-edge-defender-rankings-week-13-micah-parsons-myles-garrett-2022 :shrugs:

Pff wouldn't know line play if it smacked them in the face. Lol

I gave 4 examples that followed the same pattern. 2021 49ers trade for Lance. 1000 point difference. 2 first and 3rd Middle 2nd is worth 400 points, Middle 3rd 200 points. Bears in 2021. Point difference 370. Future 1st and 4th. Same pattern. Same valuation. Need I continue? That's 6 examples and all follow the same point pattern. As for the videos, said I couldn't do it till tonight or the morning. As for the other part, I've proven by normal stats and advanced stats that he's top 10. :shrugs:

He's a much much better fit at 3-4 OLB imo. He's decent in coverage and it helps cover him in certain areas.

https://www.espn.com/nfl/insider/insider/story/_/id/34125688/ranking-nfl-top-10-edge-rushers-2022-execs-coaches-players-make-their-picks-best-defensive-ends-linebackers It's done by nfl executives and guess what... he was top 10 on pass rushers. Hmmm, think I'll take the opinion of nfl executives over fans on a board. :shrugs:

Go back to the 2021 draft. Eagles move up from 12th to 6th. Difference in value of the picks in 2021 was 379 points. A 2nd round value. Eagles gave up a 22 1st round pick. There ya go. It's the same for every single team, it's how the draft works

Not just my rating, this is from nfl executives. he's a Top 10 edge rusher and one of the best young players in the NFL. He ranked top 25 of young defensive players and I've already linked multiple articles in this thread showing this.

Didn't say that, said that's how the valuation works out and give proof of said valuation.

It's not just about sacks. He's 4th in pressures since drafted. He's 12 in defensive stops this season. Top ten in sacks as well to be a kicker. He's a top ten dline player. Yeeesh

If your talking normal trading it's because of what I mentioned earlier. A future pick's point slot isn't guaranteed, it's 1-32 possibilities. A player to player trade or a trade within the same draft has a defined value.

I get the value of the trade in a rebuild but to think 12+ sacks is just replaceable so easy is actually quite crazy.

The videos are from draft videos after drafts and not much time to go hunting for them right now. However we can use draft trades from multiple teams last draft. Panthers 137 to 94 (value difference is 86.5 points) 4th round value difference for future 3rd pick. Colts 179 to 96th (value difference is 96.5 points) Top of the 4th round value for future 3rd Vikings 156th to 118 (value difference is 29 points) Late 5th value for future 4th.

It's not easy to replace 12 sacks. 8 players have 12 sacks or more this season.

I'll look for it tonight or in the morning, been busy at work with a full network refit.

What else is he going to say? Why yes I've spoken with NFL teams about leaving cause I hate recruiting. Lol

There's also an ESPN insider article from Matt Miller This information comes from NFL scouts and GM's. There's other post draft interviews with gms who have said the same things as well.

First on players, it depends on where the pick is at in the first. I go off what nfl teams do not fans. Heck there are teams that limit there scouts to 15 players for a first round grade. There's reasoning for this as well. It's legit how the NFL scouting world works, this next draft has 14-17 players that actually legit have a first round grade. It's also not an exact science because scouts miss all the damn time. There's articles on this and interviews with GM's talking about this.