Deangelo Williams - Best Back in the NFL

[mmmbeans]

Peterson fumbles - 4, 9 , 2

Williams fumbles - 1, 0, 3

Yards and Td's are all similar over that three year period.

are you high? the yardage isn't even close. Peterson has 900 more yards than Williams in 3 years. Not to mention almost 200 more touches.

[...]

Williams could be argued as the best in the league, for sure. The top 3 is hard to say decisively, but it would definitely consist of Peterson, Williams, and Steven Jackson (Rams)

Jackson has to deal with Marc Bulger, an inexperienced receiving corps, a horrible O-line (well, a horrible team in general) and he still puts up great numbers week in and week out.

[doomer]

I just hope that HE doesnt start imagining that when it comes time for his contract to come up...know what im sayin?

Your sig is awesome :smilewinkgrin:

[carpanfan96]

are you high? the yardage isn't even close. Peterson has 900 more yards than Williams in 3 years. Not to mention almost 200 more touches.

No, not really. Considering Dwill hasn't started but 1 1/2 season's vs a guy who has been the go to guy for his team all three years. 900 yards on 200 more touches, go back an read that again. He's gotten 200 more touches over those three years, only has 900 more yards, has around the same amount of Td's and has a lot more fumbles.

4.5 yards per carry in those 200 more touches with 15 fumbles compared to Dwill's 4/5 fumbles over that same time period.

Advantage Dwill.

[carpanfan96]

Total stats the last three years.

Peterson - 764 carries, 3885 rush yards, 5 Ypc, 582 rec yards, 32 total td's, 15 fumbles, 9 lost.

Dwill - 566 carries, 3000 yards rush, 5.3 ypc, 481 yards rec, 32 total td's, 4 fumbles, 4 lost.

[Phil Dees]

Panthers were 12-4 last year.

Don't mean poo now does it?

:frown2:

[mmmbeans]

No, not really. Considering Dwill hasn't started but 1 1/2 season's vs a guy who has been the go to guy for his team all three years. 900 yards on 200 more touches, go back an read that again. He's gotten 200 more touches over those three years, only has 900 more yards, has around the same amount of Td's and has a lot more fumbles.

4.5 yards per carry in those 200 more touches with 15 fumbles compared to Dwill's 4/5 fumbles over that same time period.

Advantage Dwill.

I'm not saying williams might not be a better back, imo the jury isn't in yet. But to say 3000 yards is almost the same as 3885 is homeristic. Williams, this year is working under the same conditions as peterson has been working under the last two, i.e. 8-9 in the box on every play. We'll see how he does. I'm not thrilled with the results thus far. That being said, he's the only one producing on offense.

[carpanfan96]

I'm not saying williams might not be a better back, imo the jury isn't in yet. But to say 3000 yards is almost the same as 3885 is homeristic. Williams, this year is working under the same conditions as peterson has been working under the last two, i.e. 8-9 in the box on every play. We'll see how he does. I'm not thrilled with the results thus far. That being said, he's the only one producing on offense.

Not thrilled, With the team overall, Yes. Dwill, No. he's averaging over 4.4 ypc, I think it's around 4.5-4.6, he's 5th in rushing yards and top 10 in touchdowns rushing.

[mmmbeans]

dwill is playing great, but he's lost two fumbles that ultimately may have cost us games. There are things that happen when you don't have a passing attack and I don't think dwill is immune to those things.