who would you rather have, jake or eli?

[tommy gun]

man both qb's looked lost this weekend. i think jake looked a little worse, (as far as turnover's go) but eli could not complete a pass to save his life. i think as far as over all career's i would have to go with jake. i know manning has the sb title, but jake has been more consistent, and better in the clutch. eli is a good qb, but way too up and down. man where is montana and marino when you need them.

[carpanfan96]

as much as I want jake gone right now, I would seriously take him over eli. Better leader and more clutch.

[YeahBoy]

jake will always be #1 in my heart

[RedMage138]

Basically 6 of one, half dozen of the other. At this point in his career, Eli is no better than Jake. Both can be inconsistent, and both have trouble when you take their number one weapon away.

[CatfanMO]

jake will always be #1 in my heart

you mean under my pecks?

[Debil]

Is there an option "C"?

[Bruce Wayne]

Eli in a heart beat. I like Jake but Eli is a much better QB and has so much potential left.

[CatfanMO]

Vince Young

[The Link]

Eli in a heart beat. I like Jake but Eli is a much better QB and has so much potential left.

He actually spreads the ball around as well.

[God]

Tyler Thigpen.

[Kevin Greene]

Gimme the Manning.

But I'd prefer Rivers.

[carpanfan96]

Eli in a heart beat. I like Jake but Eli is a much better QB and has so much potential left.

I'll give you potential but how do you say better now.

their stats are almost identical across the board for the season.

link

career wise their stats are similar in every area expect for delhomme having a big advantage in rating.....

eli

Jake

[Gokz1000]

Jake, I'll always be #1 BDJS

[God]