Newton versus Luck

[dpm0409]

Exactly. After most of these experts were made to look like fools by Cam, you would think they would hedge their bets a bit on Luck. Instead, many seem prepared to induct Luck into the Pro Football Hall of Fame.

They are doing him a huge disservice. Anything less than spectacular play will have people calling him a disappointment.

I know it, and if that were to happen, I'd feel bad for the guy. I'm not quite sure why they always tend to lean towards one extreme or the other? Never have. And it just blew up in their faces. Oh well, I guess they have to talk about something. :prrr:

[Andrew Luck]

Cam been awesome but still you guys know deep down that yall would still take me even after I screwed you guys over and stayed in school.

[Marguide]

Cam been awesome but still you guys know deep down that yall would still take me even after I screwed you guys over and stayed in school.

We would have, but then you had to go and grow that neck beard. Projecting normal growth patterns, by opening day next year, you will resemble a dark-haired Nick Mangold.

That is not the image JR wants to be his "face of the franchise".

[footballisasport]

There is nothing to compare. Newton is the greatest rookie qb of all time and Luck is a college prospect who has never won anything.

:iagree:

I love that guy name Mr Judge. He NEVER liked Cam and his argument for Luck sounds typically shallow just like the many bitter articles he has written about Cam.

[ed bell]

The best thing about wondering how good Luck will be in the NFL is that we don't have to worry about it....

No way I could envision myself saying that the day before he opted out of the 2011 draft.

[footballisasport]

Cam been awesome but still you guys know deep down that yall would still take me even after I screwed you guys over and stayed in school.

Yeah, but would u be having the same relationship with Steve Smith as Cam is having? I mean, all u hear now on these sports talk shows is how much having Cam has revived Smity and it's showing in his yards. Could u have guaranteed to give Smity the help he needed or would u have been another Jimmy Clausen once real pressure hit u?

I caught ur game last weekend and if I didn't know u for all the hype, I'd say u played no better than the QB u played against.

[ed bell]

This is so exciting....hey Andrew, are you and your dad going to make a Manning family type power play when the 2012 Draft order is finalized? That would be awesome!

[BBQ&Beer]

Cam been awesome but still you guys know deep down that yall would still take me even after I screwed you guys over and stayed in school.

Well yeah.... now. After Palmer, its clear that the Raiders would trade 1st, 2nd, & 3rd rounds til 2020 for Luck...

[edromeo]

Cam been awesome....

Are you a bit jealous or nervous over Cam Newton's success in the NFL?

Is it Cam's superior arm strength that gives him better deep ball and downfield accuracy then you?

Is that why he beat Oregon and won a national championship and the Heisman and you didn't or was it his superior athletcism?

[edromeo]

...awesome...

BTW-You're always welcome to come to Washington if you want to pull an Eli.

[Sam Mills Fan]

So damn tired of hearing about Andrew Luck and Andy Dalton. They can both suck my giant *******.

[Sematary Gates]

Andy Red Rifle Dalton is going to top THis Upcoming rookie Luck and this Brag Mouthy Cam Newton PERIOD....

[ed bell]

BTW-You're always welcome to come to Washington if you want to pull an Eli.

Interesting point, with the new rookie wage scale being tilted back towards ownership in the limiting of rookie wage structures, wouldn't that encourage high value rookies to hold out from signing for teams they don't want to play for? Eli was a family power play, but I don't remember ever seeing a #1 pick do that.

[Doc Holiday]

This is a very interesting and short read on CBSSPORTS.com. I like what they had to say, it was a very interesting discussion. Cam wins 4-2 :) http://www.cbssports.com/mcc/blogs/entry/22475988/33078939

By the way, I haven't seen this posted yet. If it was, please disregard. Thanks

Even with all the hype on Luck there are no sure things when it comes to drafting a player no matter what anyone says, right now knowing what I know, I think Luck staying in another year saved the Panthers, because you could not ask another rookie QB in the NFL to do any better then what Cam has done so far, if luck even does 3/4's of what Newton has done so far he would be considered a success.