Niners interest in Nicks

[Mr. Scot]

One year doesn't mean everything.

Put Nicks in SF & throw them in the dumpster fire that was NY & Eli last year.

 

Even throwing out last year, I'm not convinced he's better than Crabtree, and a definite no on both Boldin and Davis.

 

Edelman you've got an argument.  Not so much the others.

 

[Guest Dark Knight]

Even throwing out last year, I'm not convinced he's better than Crabtree, and a definite no on both Boldin and Davis.

Edelman you've got an argument. Not so much the others.

2011, 3rd season, age 23:

reg season- 76 Rec 1,192 Yd 7 TD 0 fmb

playoffs- 28 Rec 444 Yd 4 TD 0 fmb

He's battled injuries in the two years since that. He's still young & he's finally healthy again. He has the skills to be an elite WR, & he's actually proven it on the field.

[Mr. Scot]

2011, 3rd season, age 23:

reg season- 76 Rec 1,192 Yd 7 TD 0 fmb

playoffs- 28 Rec 444 Yd 4 TD 0 fmb

He's battled injuries in the two years since that. He's still young & he's finally healthy again. He has the skills to be an elite WR, & he's actually proven it on the field.

 

If you wanna go stats, both Crabtree and Boldin have had better years more recently.

 

[nickzz]

i would say nicks is better (injuries aside) than boldin and crabtree. davis is an absolute freak of a dude so it's hard to say nicks is better, but he's a TE so there's no point in debating who is better.

[Password is Taco]

Is DJ hackett and Drew carter still available?

[therealmjl]

Is DJ hackett and Drew carter still available?

1. Drew Carter

2. Rod Gardner

3. Ryne Robison

Super bowl.

[Guest Dark Knight]

If you wanna go stats, both Crabtree and Boldin have had better years more recently.

5 year totals

(games played, games missed)

Nicks- (74, 10) 339 Rec 5,066 Yd 31 TD 3 fmb

Crabtree- (71, 17) 319 Rec 4,145 Yd 26 TD 3 fmb