kungfoodude

It just depends on the career arc. Both coach for historically dysfunctional organizations. It probably will depend in their second, third, fourth, etc stops. I think Saleh is definitely set up for more success with 15 years of NFL coaching in his background. I think Rhule has higher potential but it's also possible he may not reach it until his second or third NFL gig. Saleh also has a track record of success as a coordinator in the league, so he is likely to continue to be employed in the NFL even if he gets fired as head coach. Rhule is sort of a jack of all trades, master of none as a coach in his career. He is probably more likely to jump back to college if he gets fired from Carolina.

https://www.espn.com/nfl/story/_/id/32121794/jacksonville-jaguars-urban-meyer-says-vaccination-status-factor-roster-cuts

It sucks but we have seen that you can basically keep trying guys out over the course of the season until you get it right. Might cost you some W's. In Detroit case, I don't think that is as big of a deterrent.

I really don't know. Some of the cuts we made were a little head scratching. Seems like when we think the staff/FO is gonna zig they zag. Don't really even mean that so much as shade as I don't think we really have enough info on what their master plan or tendencies are yet. It's sometimes hard to predict what their priorities are.

Bingo. Highly likelihood that this was why Cam was cut, IMO.

I bet I know why.....

How do we still have two long snappers?

The Huddle wouldn't be the same if people were reasonable.

I think that this Sean Gilbert trade is gonna make our DL unstoppable.

Agreed. He leaned game manager but he was a very effective NFL player. Now, admittedly, I think a bunch of that credit probably lies with Andy Reid but Smith played his part. I would definitely take "prime" Alex Smith over Sam Darnold, lower ceiling or not. And for the people complaining about Smith not being a true franchise QB, okay, fine. But pair that with the success he had in those five years and now we are a serious NFL team to contend with.

Not until contract 2 is inked.

If he was able to have the success(team winning wise) that Smith was in KC, abso-fuging-lutely. We have never even had back to back winning seasons. That would be the most successful period in franchise history and would be a big step forward in establishing us as a contending team. We can always go get another guy when the opportunity presents itself(like Mahomes) but that would be a massive step.

Well I have to drive 12 hours today, so my being up early is intentional.

In that case, PJ and Will were forged at room temp.

Yeah, he looked okay but it was still preseason. If he performs like that against the Jets, it will be a sign that we might have something.

There were 17 reps in a clean pocket in that game???

Erving, Elflein and Daley all have pretty extensive injury histories, as well. I think we will see a lot of shuffling.

Don't worry, we would. So would basically everyone else in the NFL given those two scenarios.

That's not even an honest discussion. Peak Cam was so much better than peak Jake. That's like comparing Pat Mahomes to Andy Dalton.

Yeah, I know. I hope he has a plan.

They've literally been shuffling them all offseason, so if that is an issue, they retarded the process of gelling pretty considerably. I like most of what Rhule has done with the team and the direction we are headed but I simply cannot figure out what he is doing on the OL. I hope he knows something that the rest of us don't.

I think Rhule took a flier on a younger guy that was more athletic to create some competition(wasted a pick in the process, IMO). It just didn't work out that way. By all account, JJ won that competition fairly easily.