CRA

There is no debating Bryce Young. There are just people arguing Dwyane Jarrett can get it done and life has been unfair to him…..because they can’t admit they have been so wrong about a player. MAYBE Young could get it done in the right quirky scheme with perfect skill position players. Thats not ever going to exist here nor with 98% of the other orgs

He can’t. Not by NFL standards. More than enough evidence at this stage to make that determination. For even a chance at one Bryce has to get a perfect look and that’s not NFL football. His weak arm gets nerfed too much when you get him off an ideal setup. Bryce’s ball placement and accuracy are horrible downfield. That applied at Bama. Bama WRs just had room to adjust. Bryce defenders just repeat this lie about his Bama deep ball. NFL balls have to be well placed to dudes only NFL open. Bryce leads the NFL in bad throw % since arriving. His accuracy and balls are garbage vs his peers. Countless plays for years where dudes are NFL open downfield and Bryce just lets the DB have just as good as a shot at it or takes the WR out of bounds. It’s not a debate. Dudes flat out open this year on repeat. He can’t make the throws. So the talk about not having speed is auto debunked and a distraction. Open is open and Bryce has gotten the looks

Hunter Renfrow has more TDs than every other WR combined on the roster put together Bryce can’t play beyond 20 yards. We don’t need to keep trying ton solve a riddle that has been answered. Even in the 10-20 yard range Bryce largely just plays the game to the sideline/out.

The offense is 3 of 13 with an INT when throwing downfield (20 yards) this season. We aren’t a passing offense.

Jags WRs have twice as many drops plus some as the next closest team.

Who is yall? The Bryce “haters”. This is a wild post bro. Bryce defenders jumping the shark at this point. I wanted Cam Newton before anyone was even floating he could be the #1 overall pick lol. Cam Newton is my Panthers GOAT. As a real Cam fan, it’s gross BY defenders are trying to use Cam as some sort of Bryce defense tactic. Comparing BY to Cam is also on par with comparing Jimmy Clausen to Cam. It’s pretty dang close.

Yeah, see this is where logic gets thrown out the window. Bryce Young rightfully catching heat isn’t in the same universe as Cam Newton catching whatever he got. It just makes no sense. Bryce Young has been the definition of a bad pick. You can hope all you want. Claiming what he gets is haters being haters is like claiming people were unfair to Dwayne Jarrett lol

Panthers have needed some sort of unusual occurrence to happen to find a win so if Dak has a once in a career type implosion or Renfrow randomly goes for 175 and 3TDs off Renfrow routes…..then maybe we can win. Lining up in a relatively normal game of football and winning doesn’t seem to be something we can really do. We have largely been dominated outside of weirdness happening

this explanation doesn't help their cause.

PFF always gives examples of why you pretty much have to largely just dismiss their methods at this point. Or maybe it's just select folks grading you got to dismiss but Carolina's grades always contain things that make ZERO sense. You can find it in some Bryce Young grades that make zero sense. Hell, one week Renfrow was the worst offensive player in his 15 snaps.....and he caught every catchable ball his direction, sprung Tmac for a HUGE play w/ his pick and didn't even get into run blocking that game. So it could just be some graders got bonkers subjective ways of going about it. But PFF is largely garbage for me at this point.

I think Young accounted for 4 yards on that first one. Bryce didn’t lead them. Rico got them up….after Rico got them back into a game Bryce had essentially lost them with a career effort.

Rico 10000% saved Bryce Young from being benched for the Dallas game. The way that game was going there was going to be no way to trot Bryce out next week at home if it kept going like it did. Bryce probably is safe from bench risk until the next home and home presents itself. He can’t be playing bad going into that next Atl game and then lay an egg in it.

I assume at that point Canales likely didn’t want BY to attempt a real pass because of what a nightmare he had been at that point….but you can’t be sure given how bad his throws so consistently are. I don’t think at any point he was looking for a TD because the only play on the table where he looked would have been a endzone fade f sorts to tiny Horn Jr. Which is beyond dumb.

So everyone was wondering why he was laughing… Apparently a camera man took the pass to the head. https://x.com/sharpfootball/status/1974904929447002328?s=46&t=f55N0zsNFevD-XGJBWj1-A * camera guy appeared unaffected by Bryce’s version of a fastball to the head so don’t worry about him

Your close. See last year. It’s nerves the front office will see a really bad QB improve and still be bad……and we waste EVERYONES time next year. Just like we are doing this year. Make no mistake. This is a lost and pointless year because of last years error

BY knows the playcall and he knows he doesn’t want to throw those balls. Has Bruce ever thrown TMac a good vertical ball? Not talking about a deep post. Has ever thrown a good vertical ball to any WR in his career? He sucks at it. He also doesn’t have the arm for a lot of the comeback stuff as well on the outside. The playcalls is going to make stuff a no go for BY….because he knows if his setup isn’t perfect the throw will be horrific

Hell, PJ Walker gives you that. It doesn’t take draft capital to put some warm bodies with legit NFL tools on a roster. We intentionally have the QB room we have. There is no defense to it

We certainly are going to be in the running for the top pick IMO. Start of the schedule is the easy portion….and BY has been bad in all of them. Wins came off things that can’t be replicated.

I want entertaining pass offense and and the illusion we got a punchers chance. Bryce robs us of that. we need some random miracle to pull off a win. Like a Penix implosion or a career game from a RB

Some of that is just BY and not Dave. You can go back to the preseason. BY just ain’t pulling the trigger on a lot of vertical and big plays even if it’s in the call with the coverage. His arm is weak and his balls are often bad when he does it. and no, I don’t enjoy it. I don’t want a chunk pass offense featuring a middle schooler at QB that stinks at it. Solution is to replace the QB. Not have way more bad plays.

Again, our QB is BY. we got lucky today. Big plays aren’t what we do NOR are they what we are trying to do. Again, BY is the QB. The pass game you want requires a new QB.

BY can’t and won’t make the plays you want. Playcalling isn’t going to matter

We don’t win today without Rico getting those carries. We would been blown out if the game stayed in Young’s hands down 17

Rico had 6 runs of 10+ yards. Thats a rate of every 3-4th touch went for 10+. That was a top 5 Panthers history performance AND he did that with a D only playing 20 yards and no threat of a pass. Sure Adrian Peterson had a lot of nothing runs in his good days too

Rico was awesome. That’s probably one of the top rushing performances in Panther history. It would make a top 5 list. Rico put them on his back