ForJimmy

The Niners lose when the person that is backing up Jimmy G has to play correct. You really like these stats out of context. Who was their starting QBs in these loses? Replace him with a capable QB and you could have a Rams/Stafford moment with that team. I posted what CRA shared with us in this thread and Intended Air Yards Per Attempt. Do you care to comment on his playoff performances? Winning one or two more games so Rhule can try to keep his job isn't the best play for the Panthers. Jimmy is already on his 3rd team by age 30 and we would be number 4. I don't hate him, but let's actually learn from our mistakes and not keep repeating them with other team's castoff QBs. I don't hate Sam Darnold, but I understand he isn't the future of the Panthers and the same goes for Jimmy.

@poundaway

Sam is already fumbling in OTAs....

Lol look what happens in the playoffs. They win but he shits the bed, they needed a blocked punt for a TD to get score so they could beat GB in which Jimmy had a QBR of 11. Hell Sam could have gotten a rating of 11. His win against Dallas 0 TDs 1 INT and under 200 yards passing. He looked better against the Rams, but threw the game deciding INT to lose the game. Teddy's regular season passer rating was 94.9 last year landing him just a couple spots behind Jimmy. Jimmy dinks and dunks/checkdowns just like Teddy (I think someone posted he was 29th in yards per attempt). It gives them a good rating, but when the game is on the line they can't make the plays to win. There is a reason why he is STILL available. If he was so great we would all be wanting him and there would be a bidding war for him right now. We aren't "too good" for him. It's just a waste of resources to trade for a mediocre QB that is basically Teddy 2.0 just to get a couple more wins. We need to develop Corral or draft our next franchise QB next year.

It kind of sounds like the Cards are going to pay him based on how their coach is responding. Hopefully we stay put.

But Jimmy G isn't the one wanting to move on. His team wants to move on from him even if he wants to stay. As Mr Scot just shared we don't want to pay his salary which is reflective of a good QB. I wonder why that is??? In fact it doesn't look like ANY team is wanting to pay that salary for a subpar QB...

Just like Teddy in Minnesota! Let's try THAT again...

Have they considered Gettleman?

Super Bowl victories are so hard to come by. That's why the NE dynasty was so impressive. I think Tomlin is the only active head coach with more than one Super Bowl victory (as head coach) outside of Bill.

They need to just trrade his ass away and eat most of the salary. It's what he did with Teddy. Seattle seems like an ideal spot for him to step in a compete right away.

It would take a healthy CMC, solid OL play (possible with the talent there), and the big one for me is Corral showing some promise. That plus YGM or another young defender stepping up and we could be a playoff team. I still think we are a year or two away even if Corral shows some potential. I'm just happy we finally have a potential franchise LT and some talent/competition for Darnold in the QB room.

Yep. Give Corral a chance to play this season to see if there is anything there. That will let us decided if we draft one from the next draft class or not. I could give two shits about Rhule getting an extra win or two with Baker/Jimmy. I want us to get some stability at the QB position.

Seriously! He always looks good in practice. He just can't read real defenses...

Come running to Snyder's defense! Don't be so damn predictable...

That doesn't mean moving on from Jimmy is the wrong move. Lance is an unknown in which no team knows more about him than the Niners. You have a strange notation that if a team makes one mistake they are destined to make mistakes over and over again. I mean the Patriots made a mistake in not signing Brady what he thought he was worth right? We made one in trading for Sam so I guess trading for Jimmy would be us continuing to make mistakes as well...

Our OL looks SO much better than last year. I’ll give credit where credit it due. Their top goal was to address the OL and they absolutely did. That in itself should make us more competitive as they gel and develop throughout the season. I’m hoping another WR like Shi or Rambo steps up and gets some playing time as well. We seem to have a decent roster while thin at a few spots. Next year will be a big offseason. Aside from the QB situation there isn’t too many weaknesses. LB and DT could still get filled in as teams make cuts this year.

They wanted to roll with Jimmy that year and after another year of letting them down they became eager to move on. It’s really not hard to follow. It obviously was the wrong move in hindsight just like Mitch to the bears. It doesn’t mean they are smart just they realized their mistake. They weren’t going to get any better with Jimmy at QB. We did it with Teddy and Sam. Teams chose the wrong QB all the time. Hell even the Jets did it with Sam and we traded for him. That turned out great… You on the other hand are wanting their mistake on our team.

Really?

Why a team would trade away 3 first rounds picks to replace their good 29 year old QB and why he is STILL available in late May? Yeah it’s not confusing, it’s because he is overpaid for a below average QB. No team is eager to trade away assets and take on his full contract. Similar to Baker right now. He is heading to his 3rd team by age 30 IF a team actually trades for him. Teddy 2.0

If you think he is good that’s your opinion. I’ve seen him when his running game isn’t going and they need to use his arm and it’s gets bad. Check those stats for the postseason and watch what happens to them. It’s easy to dink and dunk when you have a great defense and the running game is going great. When they needed his arm he isn’t able to get the job done. It’s very similar to Teddy with the Vikings. I’d rather roll with Corral and if he isn’t the answer then draft one next year. If you want to try to trade for or sign another team’s cast off for the 3rd year in a row, then hopefully 3rd times a charm. I just don’t see it… QBR has Tannehill and Wentz in the top 10 over him. These guys are behind great running offenses. When the games on the line they have proven they can’t get it done.

Those would look a lot bigger if Kenny Pickett was holding them...

You thought teams didn't make mistakes? Jimmy G isn't that good and that's why he is STILL available and the Niners have been so eager to replace him. Jimmy is better than Sam. I agree with you there. We can sign Foles right now as a FA who is better than Sam. That's an extremely low bar to have...

Are you talking about before or after they held an emergency meeting with the front office and Rodgers, restructured his contract, gave him the input he had been wanting then signed him to a huge contract he was wanting? That's just GB making it right and giving him what he wanted. Rodgers wants to be there now.