Jump to content
  • Welcome!

    Register and log in easily with Twitter or Google accounts!

    Or simply create a new Huddle account. 

    Members receive fewer ads , access our dark theme, and the ability to join the discussion!

     

All Time Team


London Loves Luke

Recommended Posts

QB1: Cam form any year

QB2: Jake Delhomme from '03

RB1: Deangelo from '08

RB2: Stewart from '09

RB3: Tolbert

FB: Hoover

WR1: Smitty

WR2: Muhammad

WR3: Benji... it's sad that he's a rookie and already showing he might be one of our team's better receivers throughout history

TE1: Greg Olsen

TE2: Walls

O-Line. I'll be honest, I didn't know enough about football at the beginning of their existence to give an educated guess at who was good and who wasn't. Here's some I know were good at one point:

Gross

Wharton

Kalil

Whale

Piggy

DE: Peppers

DE: Kraken circa last year

DT: Jenkins

DT: KK from this year

OLB: Beason the year Davis got hurt the first time. He did fine at OLB that year.

MLB: Luke

OLB: Davis

CB: Gamble

CB: Eric Davis

Slot CB: Captain. Sucked on the outside, great inside.

S: Minter

S: Mitchell from last year

K: Kasay

P: Nortman

KR: Bates

PR: Smitty

Captian has to be the panthers all time best nickel back. I was wondering are we picking players whole careers or just their best season?

Some players I am suprised no one has put on their list or should be recognized more are:

Jake Delhomme ( until Cam passes him, jake is out all time best QB, and won some big playoff games.)

Ken Lucas

Will Witherspoon

Micheal Rucker

No Ricky Proehl? The guy was one of the panthers most clutch receivers and was a solid slot receiver. I have no doubt he, Smith and Moose was the best trio of WRs the Panthers ever had.

I think Brenston Buckner was a great player for us but didn't always get the credit he deserves because he had Jenkins and Peppers on the offensive line with him.

Also all time panthers best full back to me is a close one. Hoover spent his entire career a panther and was one hell of a blocker. Tolbert is a beast and is a great offensive weapon, but not a great blocker and hasn't been a panther long.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Offense 

 

QB- Cam Newton- sorry but if you give Cam the OL jake had, the defense, Stephen Davis, and Steve/Moose in their primes we probably win multiple Super bowls

RB- Deangelo Williams

RB- Jonathan Stewart 

WR- Steve Smith

WR- Muhsin Muhammad 

TE- Wesley Walls/Greg Olsen - solid debate on this one

LT- Jordan Gross

LG- Kevin Donnally

C- Ryan Kalil

RG- Travelle Wharton

RT- Jeff Otah - guy was a complete animal at his peak, huge part of that dominate run game we had in 08

 

 

Defense 

 

LE - Julius Peppers

DT- Kris Jenkins

DT- Star Lotulelei from last season

RE- Greg Hardy

 

LB- Sam Mills, Dan Morgan, Luke Kuechly, Jon Beason - Dan Morgan at his peak before the concussions was a stud. Couldve been one of the greats honestly. Beason in his peak was a superstar as well. Thomas Davis and Lamar Lathon are valid arguments too

 

CB - Eric Davis, Chris Gamble, Ken Lucas - tough for me to choose two from these three. Lucas in 05 was one of the best in the game

Nickel - Captain Munnerlyn - no debate here

 

SS - Mike Minter

FS - Mike Mitchell - the numbers dont lie, and he was the attitude of the defense, weve also never really had a consistently good FS ever

 

K- John Kasay

P- Todd Sauerbrun

 

KR- Michael Bates

PR - Steve Smith

Special Teamers - Karl Hankton, Colin Jones

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Captian has to be the panthers all time best nickel back. I was wondering are we picking players whole careers or just their best season?

Some players I am suprised no one has put on their list or should be recognized more are:

Jake Delhomme ( until Cam passes him, jake is out all time best QB, and won some big playoff games.)

Ken Lucas

Will Witherspoon

Micheal Rucker

No Ricky Proehl? The guy was one of the panthers most clutch receivers and was a solid slot receiver. I have no doubt he, Smith and Moose was the best trio of WRs the Panthers ever had.

I think Brenston Buckner was a great player for us but didn't always get the credit he deserves because he had Jenkins and Peppers on the offensive line with him.

Also all time panthers best full back to me is a close one. Hoover spent his entire career a panther and was one hell of a blocker. Tolbert is a beast and is a great offensive weapon, but not a great blocker and hasn't been a panther long.

 

 

I'm picking at their best - its kind of easier to choose based on best performances instead of on people's careers where it gets harder to judge. But agree on the captain and rucker shout outs. 05 Lucas is an interesting one after that season but I'm not sure he can beat out Gamble and Davis for an All Time spot off the back of that one season. 

 

Not sure I agree on the Buckner call, by the time he got to us I think the others on the line we're making him look a bit better then he was. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm picking at their best - its kind of easier to choose based on best performances instead of on people's careers where it gets harder to judge. But agree on the captain and rucker shout outs. 05 Lucas is an interesting one after that season but I'm not sure he can beat out Gamble and Davis for an All Time spot off the back of that one season.

Not sure I agree on the Buckner call, by the time he got to us I think the others on the line we're making him look a bit better then he was.

Buckner never had the stats. There were many times Jenkins went down and Buck had to step it up. He by no means was a probowl caliber player but to me he was a solid player for many years.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


×
×
  • Create New...