Jump to content
  • Welcome!

    Register and log in easily with Twitter or Google accounts!

    Or simply create a new Huddle account. 

    Members receive fewer ads , access our dark theme, and the ability to join the discussion!

     

American Idol tiers


g5jamz

Recommended Posts

as of March 29 - and my opinion only. I feel that more women watch it than men, and that's why you've seen the "bad" women out first. I think we'll start seeing the "bad" men from tier 3 fall the next few weeks, with maybe a surprise in Tier 2, but doubtful.

Tier 1 (in no particular order)

Casey James - mad guitar skillz...but he needs to spit the dip out before singing

profile_photos_90x180.jpg

Mike Lynche - solid

profile_photos_90x180.jpg

Crystal Bowersox - she's still got a couple of shades of teeth whitening left...but insane good

profile_photos_90x180.jpg

Siobhan Magnus - still a favorite, but ditzy as heck

profile_photos_90x180.jpg

Tier 2

Aaron Kelly - looks like a caricature or a Mad Magazine character.

profile_photos_90x180.jpg

Lee Dewyze - don't know if America is ready for another soul patrol...

profile_photos_90x180.jpg

Katie Stevens - has disappointed but she's got crazy skills. Hope the next time she belts it out and doesn't sound so suppressed.

profile_photos_90x180.jpg

Didi Benami - niche voice...tough to win a competition with that voice. Reminds me of the one-armed tattoo chick from last year

profile_photos_90x180.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Tier 3 - one should go home this week...

Andrew Garcia - was awful last week. Don't know what to say...thought he was amazing at the outset, but fallen off badly. I mean off a cliff bad. Has to get original...in a good way.

profile_photos_90x180.jpg

Tim Urban - no relation to Keith Urban. Has had one good week...that's about it. I didn't think last week's was horrible, but he's not in the same class.

profile_photos_90x180.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Move Katie Stevens & Casey James down a level and you'd have it right.

Katie needs a few years with a coach before she is ready. Great raw talent but no control and little idea what to do with it.

Casey is just a mediocre vocalist on his best day.

I could see that...

I guess I was just tiering based on what I think the general public thinks. I don't see Casey in any danger of being voted out for quite a while.

Talentwise...I would agree with you. I'll do a prediction tiering post-Tuesday performances.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


  • PMH4OWPW7JD2TDGWZKTOYL2T3E.jpg

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Seriously? Rub some dirt in it and get back on the field. 
    • hiring matt rhule and giving him full control was maybe the worst singular decision this franchise has ever made outside of Rae Caruth 
    • Vikings bring back WR Thielen from Panthers Vikings get: WR Adam Thielen, conditional 2026 seventh-round pick, 2027 fifth-round pick Panthers get: 2026 fifth-round pick, 2027 fourth-round pick Vikings grade: A- Panthers grade: C+ The Vikings have re-united with their longtime receiver Adam Thielen. Assuming the conditions of the 2026 pick headed to Minnesota are met, the Vikings will have moved back two rounds in next year's draft and one round in 2027's draft to acquire the single year remaining on the 35-year-old receiver's contract. This is fine business. The Vikings' receiver depth will be tested early this season, as WR3 speedster Jalen Nailor recovers from a hand injury and WR2 Jordan Addison serves a three-game suspension. Depth receiver Rondale Moore had a season-ending knee injury early this offseason, leaving rookie Tai Felton and veteran Tim Jones as the depth behind Justin Jefferson to start the season. Thielen should slot right into a familiar offense and provide a good safety blanket for young quarterback J.J. McCarthy, who needs strong early performances in September to boost his confidence and generate some positive momentum. I like the deal a lot for that reason: McCarthy won't spend the first three starts of his NFL career endeavoring to make up for bad receiver play. This is actually a bigger risk for the Panthers than it appears. From Week 8 on last season -- the stretch in which quarterback Bryce Young came back and looked solid -- Thielen was the Panthers' best receiver. Sure, guys like Jalen Coker and Ja'Tavion Sanders were having breakout games, and the backs were getting involved as pass catchers, but it was Thielen who drove the ship. Thielen averaged 2.47 yards per route run in that stretch, which was the 14th best number in the NFL. He also caught 80% of his targets when Coker and Xavier Legette caught 63.2% and 56.4%, respectively. Thielen was so valuable that the Panthers gave him a raise in March worth $1.5 million to encourage him to stave off retirement. The drafting of first-round receiver Tetairoa McMillan always foretold a decrease in target share for Thielen. But keeping Thielen around for another year would have helped smooth the transition. Now the Panthers enter the season with a starting receiver trio (McMillan, Coker and Legette) full of big-play potential but no proven chemistry with Young over the middle of the field. That's an important cornerstone of the Panthers' offensive system that needs replacing. -- Solak
×
×
  • Create New...