Replay?

[Squirrel]

Why doesnt MLB have replay? Perfect game lost because of a bad call.

[Panthro]

Because human judgement and error is part of the game

[Swarly]

if they don't give this guy a perfect game it'll be so fuged up. it has absolutely zero effect on the outcome of the game, so it's not like it'll matter.

what makes it worse is he didn't go from perfect game to no hitter. he went from perfect game to NOTHING.

[Fiz]

lol out 27

[holderoftruth]

I dont think replay would take away from the game if it was implemented right. Have a couple guys watching replays and then send it down to the field. It wouldnt take longer than 1 minute. It takes longer for players to walk to the dugout and walk into the batters box.

That call was fuged up though.

[PanthersFanNY]

Terrible call. He got screwed but I admire how he handled it.

A lot of pitchers would have gotten into it right there, but he just went back to work.

[Miaoww]

fug that poo. Hilarious.

[BF91]

I'm a firm believer that each manager should get one "challenge" per game. Not on balls and strikes, but on home run calls and plays like that one.

[Dpantherman]

one reason why I hate baseball

[Dpantherman]

I can't wait until a blown call caused by "human error" costs the Yankees a World Series, bc thats the only way it will change. screw 'em. Go Braves but screw the MLB

[pstall]

Because human judgement and error is part of the game

TOTALLY agree. Plus it would take away the awesome phrase of " a bang bang play at 3rd"

[Swarly]

give managers a "challenge" type rule like coaches have in Football. let them challenge one or 2 plays every game. problem solved.

[tarheelblue89]

TOTALLY agree. Plus it would take away the awesome phrase of " a bang bang play at 3rd"

I agree that it is part of the game.

But was that really a bang-bang play? I think it was pretty obvious.

I feel bad for the guy, but he didn't say one thing to the ump. Which is pretty classy IMO.

[Starscream]

I feel bad for the guy, but he didn't say one thing to the ump. Which is pretty classy IMO.

This.^^^

No argument, he just smiled. Class act. I would have knocked the ump the f out, though.