Halo Reach or Madden?

[Paintballr]

So I want a new game but don't know which one to get. I haven't gotten madden in two years. Been playing NCAA every year but not madden. Same thing with Halo. Haven't played it since Halo 2. Played 3 briefly but not much. Enjoy but styles of games but I want to play one with a lot of replay value and won't get tired of. Any suggestions?

[Falcons1stPanthers2nd]

Neither. Madden hasn't done poo since 2003. Just updated rosters and charged 60 bucks. Halo never appealed to me much.

[WhoDatJorts]

If I had to choose, I would probably get Reach. I like this year's Madden but it's not something I can sit and play for hours. Reach definitely has more replay value, IMO.

[SorthNarolina]

Reach by a long shot. Madden just isn't fun for me at all. Halo Reach has made me feel like I'm 11 again. I haven't enjoyed/played a video game that much in a long time.

[Paintballr]

Sounds good, Ill probably go get reach today then. Anyone got a gamertag? Ill be on all tonight and tomorrow if it's that good.