Brayton or Johnson?

[The Answer]

People are pretty high on Jonhson, not that they shouldn't be, he has done a great job, but I think Brayton has done an solid job starting. Yes, he does over run some plays and he isn't always in the play, but neither is Pep. Brayton has done a great job in run defense, and just shows glimpses of amazing strength when he pushed tackles onto their asses. So I'm asking who do you think should be starting Johnson or Brayton, Not saying Johnson shouldn't start but just don't undermine what Brayton has done for us this season.

[Ashor]

Charles Johnson was an impact player down in Georgia.

[Fiz]

Brayton makes one play and all of a sudden his mediocrity is forgotten

[The Answer]

Fiz, I'm not basing anything off of the 2 plays he had on Garcia, I have been watching him since he came in, and even watched hilights of him on the Raiders, assuming makes an Ass of U and Me

[megadeth078]

Brayton is great against the run, and he provides some good pressure. I like him as the starter.

It's funny that Fiz says that considering the only good thing Johnson has shown, in terms of displaying starter material, is a play here and there.

[BlindSite]

I like Brayton he's only just switched back to DE after having two years out of the position and he's played pretty well. I say he keeps the starting job but keep rotating Johnson in on passing downs like we've been doing.

I don't think the team would perform any better with Brayton as the rotational guy over Johnson, so why change now?

[Fiz]

It's funny that Fiz says that considering the only good thing Johnson has shown, in terms of displaying starter material, is a play here and there.

yeah I never said anything about Johnson there thanks for trying

Fiz, I'm not basing anything off of the 2 plays he had on Garcia, I have been watching him since he came in

then you have diminished expectations of what a starting DE should be doing.

[megadeth078]

anyways, I think he's doing a great job.

[House]

Leave it alone for now, with Brayton as the starter and Johnson getting considerable minutes. Next year though I think that Johnson will be the starter. He is going to be a very good DE for us in years to come. I like what Brayton has done for us this year and he has definetly revived his career but I think that Johnson has much more potential. This is really just his first year in the league, he only played in what, the last 3 games last year. He will be a force beside Pep next year.

[Snake]

Brayton is good at the run and Johnson is good at pass rush. Nether one is good a both so thats why we are gonna keep both. Untill we see something from one of them or from another player.

[hdevonxz]

Brayton is the better every down player but then again johnson hasn't gottrn an opportunity to play every down. Johnson is certainly the better pass rusher.

[hdevonxz]

Brayton is the better every down player but then again johnson hasn't gottrn an opportunity to play every down. Johnson is certainly the better pass rusher.

[ChucktownK]

Brayton makes one play and all of a sudden his mediocrity is forgotten

"One play", c'mon he's made a few good plays almost every game. He has given some big plays on occasion but he's solid. Not to mention he did set the tempo for the defense the last game. Remember the 1st play?

[SorthNarolina]

Johnson needs more polish, he's missed around 4 easy sacks that no vet would miss ever

I see brayton as more of a stop gap, i think if the team concentrates more on DT in the offseason it's possible he could stay