SmokinwithWilly

I don't know that he needs game experience as much as he needs time to adjust to the complexities of an NFL offense and the speed of the players. He's never played with this level of talent. Depending on how fast he picks it up, maybe insert him by game 8 to 10. If he ends up having a successful 12-15 year career, will anyone care he sat out most of his rookie year?

So you're saying we move from 1 to 2 to 4? What would the trade compensation be?

Accepted it, yes. Excited, meh. I think we have the coaching staff with the right experience to actually develop a QB. While he might not be ready right away, I think with a staff like this, you have to take a shot on AR. He could be something special. That's not saying Young won't be good, I just think his ceiling is lower.

That's what made JaMarcus Russell one of the biggest busts in NFL history. It wasn't just the pick. That was the equivalent to signing Jimmy Pickles to a 70m contract.

One way to do it could be to set a limit on the amount of cap space dedicated to a particular area of the team. Say 55% offense, 40% defense and 5% special teams. Teams could still throw whatever number they wanted at a particular player, but they would have to allocate it from that % block.

There really should be an out for injury retirement like Luke had. That's not anyone's fault, it's just part of the game. There should be something to at least offset part of that cap hit because you've lost a player to something beyond either party's control.

What if he makes the ProBowl, for the Texans? Don't worry. AR will be too busy prepping for the SB.

Somewhere in one of the infinite parallel universes the Panthers are 9 time in a row defending SB Champs. I like to think we're those guys.

Maybe, maybe not. Their OL was atrocious last year. Grabbing an OT at 7 if they can get the Raiders to move up, or another team if it's not to far a fall, might not be a bad idea. Raimman wasn't good last year. They need help at RG. Add a WR or TE depending on who's available, get the offense setup ready, and insert rookie QB. Could be a good way to optimize rookie contract value and get into playoff contention in a hurry.

No matter who we pick, I hope we take the most time possible to get it in. Though I do expect a cutaway right as it's being announced, you know because, Panthers.

Might be time to think about trading for Evans in my FF dynasty leagues. Definitely a buy low candidate now.

Maybe. I think the only catastrophic meltdown would be if it was Levis. AR as a prospect is very intriguing. He obviously doesn't have the experience that CJ or BY have, but he does have the physical tools and his ceiling is higher. That said, it all depends on if he can be developed or not. I'm of the opinion that we take the best prospect and develop him. If that's CJ, BY, or AR, that should be the pick. What they can do now is less important to me than what they can become later.

Nah man. It was all in jest and good fun.

Probably because Ron always finds a way to squeak out a win when it matters the least.

Can't see Ryans letting that culture in the building. Doesn't strike me as that kind of guy. They could roll with Davis Mills and see what happens, but I don't think anyone is beating Tampa to the suck bowl this year.

Could be rolling with Davis Mills and playing for the top pick next year. 4 QBs in the top 10 not looking likely.

Did someone photoshop his prom picture?

The problem for arguing AR at 1 is he needs time to develop and this is a win now league. All 4 of these QBs have some kind of issue. Since that's the case, I'd rather go highest ceiling, but I get why we won't.

I know it's becoming that the franchise QB is the end all be all of success in the NFL and it just isn't true. We all saw what happened to Cam with a bad oline. Plus you need someone to actually catch, and a few guys on defense to actually stop people. If you want above average to elite at any of those other positions you're going to have to make some serious sacrifices in other areas. A little ego check for some of these guys making 50-60m per season might be coming when they get planted into the turf repeatedly because they have an offensive line made up of Byron Bells.

So what you're saying is to feel better we just need to go out and get a Hooker?

Still zero. NFL hated Cam for playing the game the way he did. They wouldn't have let it happen.

There needs to be a QB cap limit just like there was a NFL rookie cap limit. If these contracts don't get under control, there's going to be some pretty hard feelings coming from the other guys who can't get paid because $65m a year isn't enough.

FIFY

You don't necessarily have your franchise QB. We've seen too many high pick QBs fail. There are no guarantees in the NFL draft when it comes to making the transition from college to the pros.

Because if someone else makes you a ridiculous offer and you're not sold on 1 of the 3 as the best, you can still get a QB and some other pieces and improve the team. Have to at least show some interest in all of them to give yourself the most opportunities if you're not 100%.