Pantherxtreme

He didn't think Cam was going to be a good Qb coming out of Auburn and stated Gabbert was the best prospect and then Cam came out and set the league on fire his rookie season and Bradshaw was sore ever since.

Donald inherited two 1000 yard receivers when he came to this team and he can't get the ball to them. He threw for 111 yards last game, how much building does he need? A probowler at every position to succeed. If we got Watson this oline will look much better than they do now. They didn't look this bad last season with pretty much the same lineup.

We had #1 draft picks prior to 2003 and we were a middle of the road team until a journey man player emerged as our franchise QB and led us to the Superbowl. We had #1 draft picks prior to 2010 and was the worst team in the NFL prior to drafting Cam. Moral of the story you need a QB to win in this league if you have a bonafide franchise guy you have a better chance than most at winning

I'm on board. QB is a glaring need on this team and we have a chance to get an elite QB still in his prime. Go for it.

Those same moral police consumed the NFL product even though Roethlisberger was able to play out a full hall of fame career and win Super bowls. Morality shouldn't stop at your favorite team. If it was really about morals you would distance yourself from the NFL completely.

Nah I don't have any faith in this coaching staff selecting the right rookie Qb or developing him. Heck they thought they could develop Sam Donald, I'll rather get a proven vet like Stafford or Watson. You saw a vet like Teddy even with his limited physical skills mask their incompetence to as we were competitive in a rebuilding year. Now this season we're getting blown off the field by 1 win teams.

And now Brady's offense is putting up 3 points against the woeful Giants. Maybe he needs to follow Teddy out the building.

Should have stuck with Teddy and let him be the Bridge (heck it's in his name) until you find an upgrade at Qb. The offense would be able to play much more complimentary football with an improved defense, definitely would have a better record and still have our draft picks to boot. Total mismanagement.

Exactly once a team knows your offense can't move the ball or score they start calling the game differently taking shots that they may not have without the fear of a turnover or mistake costing them. You hold a team to 5 points at the half, they should be playing from behind not sitting comfortable with a lead. All the Giants needed to do is point 1 more score on the board and that game was practically over.

The only two games you can say the defense hasn't played well enough to get us a win if we had a competent offense would be the Dallas game and to a lesser intent the Vikings. We were up 15-6 on the Eagles midway into the the 3rd quarter when our offense and special teams decided they wanted to play give away. The first 3 weeks the defense was putting up historic numbers, I don't think anyone expected that type of dominance to remain for the entirety of the season that would have put us statistically as the best defense of all time. What we needed was for our offense to step up and let our defense get after some folks but instead the last few weeks we've played defenses ranked much worse than our own and they have looked like the better defense on the field because our offense is just that inept.

And when he does check it down it's an inaccurate ball where our receivers have to do a pirouette just to get their hands on the ball and the result is no YAC at all.

Defense held the Giants to 5 points at the half that's a baseball score. We went for it on 4th down at like our own 25 yard line and failed to convert you can't keep putting your defense in that position and think can win the game for you.

We didn't expect the offense to look worse than it did a season ago when we legit had the pandemic as an excuse. Definitely didn't expect it to look like the worst in the league.

Joe Brady and Donald making every defense we play look like the 85 bears.

This clown in his presser said Sam's still the QB going forward. Talk about a train wreck. I doubt we win another game the rest of the way and all of our picks got traded away. Looks like rebuild in year 2 is in a major setback.

PJ came in the game when we had to pass to get back in it. Easy for the defense to pin the ears back. I'm sure we would have scored more than 3 had he played the entire game. The Donald experience needs to be over.

Game is more than likely lost and Donald contributed greatly to the results.

Didnt he interview for the Jets job. Looks like he finally got his chance to coach Donald lol.

They can't that would mean they were wrong jettison Teddy and trading picks for Donald. I think they are going to go down with the ship. I say good riddance if that's the case.

Lol at all the guys acting like the OP was insane for suggesting PJ. I mean how are we going to score 3 points in a whole half against the terrible Giants if Walker gets inserted into the lineup.

Teddy is a way better QB than this guy. Our offense wasn't this hapless last season. We actually did the ball just couldn't score enough Redzone TD's. This offense is a top 3 pick in the draft level bad.

This offense may be the worst in the league.

3 points at the half. I wonder what excuses our "gunslinger" fans have for this game. If Rhule doesn't bring PJ out to start after half, I completely lost faith in this staff to be anything but bottom feeders.

Wouldn't the name change to Big Ben be more appropriate given the occupation.

Poor eyesight is as well.