Mr. Scot
-
Posts
140,631 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Huddle Wiki
Forums
Gallery
Everything posted by Mr. Scot
-
The protection problems make it extremely hard to properly evaluate him.
-
Best answer I could give to that honestly is this... If you were to ask me who was the better quarterback between Joe Montana and Dan Marino, I'd say Dan Marino. But ask me (or anyone, honestly) who had the better career, pretty much everybody is going to say Montana. The difference, of course, was the teams around them. That's where we have to look as well...
-
The question is self-awareness. Bad bosses tend not to know they're bad bosses.
-
You could make a pretty good argument that he looked decent yesterday...minus a couple of absolute killer plays. But then you can't rightly take those plays out of the equation, so...
-
O can't get there without knowing for certain where Tepper stood in this. If he's meddling, he's got no business firing anybody, But even if he didn't, I have so little trust in him that I wouldn't want him making so much as one more decision.
-
That's a nightmare scenario to me, especially if it involves Tepper making the decisions,
-
Wouldn't go that far There are definitely some positives on the team and some things to build around. It is, however, valid to say they are in the first year of a rebuild.
-
That is a pet peeve I have with Frank. Also have some questions about the depth chart / personnel decisions given the last two games. Still think it's too soon to wrote him off, though,
-
Everybody else did too, and largely because they knew it wasn't a real option.
-
It being his choice is part of the question, but even if it is a lot of great drafters have whiffed on QB picks before. Hell, Bobby Beathard was a legend but he's also known as the guy who traded up to take Ryan Leaf.
-
No, not solely on McCown. Just as an example, one of the rumors re: Stroud is that the S2 test eliminated him in Tepper's eyes.
-
Nobody was ever getting Jackson away from the Ravens. The non-exclusive tag was only put there to let other teams negotiate parameters that the Ravens would have just matched.
-
I wouldn't go that far on either the franchise or Young. It's one thing to say Stroud might be better, another thing entirely to say Young is bad. Young still has plenty of strengths that can be built on.
-
Don't think I've ever said any different about Tepper. I did say he was at least capable of learning, but Reich's comments about his level of involvement have me concerned again.
-
I've come to accept that Moton at LT is just never gonna happen. Fir the scheme we're running though, it'd make some sense. What I think (hope) ultimately happens is he goes to left guard and we got a more WCO type tackle next year.
-
That's a real possibility.
-
I think you ultimately do but It's a pretty tough discussion to have right now
-
I don't doubt that that's the decision they ultimately agreed upon because that's who we drafted. My question is how it got to that point.
-
The most obvious solution would be moving the left tackle to left guard, but then you've arguably got an even bigger problem.
-
I know he talked to Polian regarding Reich. Polian is a big Frank Reich fan. How he feels about Fitterer or anyone else, no one can say. Colbert would make a more natural choice. They're reported to be friends, but Colbert at least officially still has a position with the Steelers.
-
Nah...Voice to text makes it easy. Mind you, it also makes it easy to make glaring mistakes that I don't see you until the editing window is closed
-
See above...
-
I hear Nicole Tepper tied to Young a lot but I don't know that it's valid. She had a pretty good connection with CJ Stroud as well, to the point that he referred to her as Mama Tepp. On the whole though, it's hard to sort through the rumors
-
I think a couple of folks have already responded as far as where the rumors came from. But again, this is an area where we don't fully know what's going on. That's why I posted a couple of different possibilities
-
I'd be in favor of this but we've got a glaring problem at left guard.
