Jump to content
  • Welcome!

    Register and log in easily with Twitter or Google accounts!

    Or simply create a new Huddle account. 

    Members receive fewer ads , access our dark theme, and the ability to join the discussion!

     

Consensus Draft Big Board rankings


panther4life

Recommended Posts

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1ok_bhWEHjupSdmOp1hF_puC7urYfzIY7Ar5hXNKAJvY/edit#gid=1935070314

Best one I can currently find. Uses 8 different big boards including, espn scouts inc, nfl,and CBS. 

Top prospects by positions of interest to us shook out like this. Positional ranking/Overall ranking

RB 

  1. Barkley, 1st overall
  2. Guice, 15th
  3. Ronald Jones, 32nd
  4. Michel 36th
  5. Chubb 41st
  6. Penny 68th
  7. Kerryon Johnson 69th

WR.

  1. Ridley 12th
  2. Sutton 27th
  3. D.J Moore 42nd
  4. Kirk 44th
  5. Washington 48th
  6. Anthony Miller 59th
  7. Deon Cain 70th
  8. DJ Chark 72nd

Safety

  1. Fitzpatrick 4th
  2. James  5th
  3. Harrison 33rd
  4. Reid 40th
  5. Bates 61st

CB 

  1.  Ward 10th
  2. Jackson 14th
  3. Alexander 23rd
  4. Oliver 29th
  5. Hughes 34th
  6. Carlton Davis 46th
  7. Donte Jackson 52nD

Edge Rushers

  1. Chubb 3rd
  2. Davenport 18th
  3. Landry 20th
  4. Arden Key 39th
  5. Hubbard 45th

O-lineman

  1. Nelson (Guard) 2nd
  2. McGlinchey (Tackle) 22nd
  3. Hernandez (Guard) 24th
  4. Wynn (Guard) 26th
  5. Billy Price (Guard/Center) 30th
  6. Connor Williams (Tackle) 31st
  7. James Daniels(Center) 38th
  8. Kolton Miller (Tackle) 47th
  9. Orlando Brown (Tackle) 53rd

T.E

  1. Goedert 37th
  2. Gesicki 50th
  3. Hurst 67th

 

 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 hours ago, panther4life said:

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1ok_bhWEHjupSdmOp1hF_puC7urYfzIY7Ar5hXNKAJvY/edit#gid=1935070314

Best one I can currently find. Uses 8 different big boards including, espn scouts inc, nfl,and CBS. 

Top prospects by positions of interest to us shook out like this. Positional ranking/Overall ranking

RB 

  1. Barkley, 1st overall
  2. Guice, 15th
  3. Ronald Jones, 32nd
  4. Michel 36th
  5. Chubb 41st
  6. Penny 68th
  7. Kerryon Johnson 69th

WR.

  1. Ridley 12th
  2. Sutton 27th
  3. D.J Moore 42nd
  4. Kirk 44th
  5. Washington 48th
  6. Anthony Miller 59th
  7. Deon Cain 70th
  8. DJ Chark 72nd

Safety

  1. Fitzpatrick 4th
  2. James  5th
  3. Harrison 33rd
  4. Reid 40th
  5. Bates 61st

CB 

  1.  Ward 10th
  2. Jackson 14th
  3. Alexander 23rd
  4. Oliver 29th
  5. Hughes 34th
  6. Carlton Davis 46th
  7. Donte Jackson 52nD

Edge Rushers

  1. Chubb 3rd
  2. Davenport 18th
  3. Landry 20th
  4. Arden Key 39th
  5. Hubbard 45th

O-lineman

  1. Nelson (Guard) 2nd
  2. McGlinchey (Tackle) 22nd
  3. Hernandez (Guard) 24th
  4. Wynn (Guard) 26th
  5. Billy Price (Guard/Center) 30th
  6. Connor Williams (Tackle) 31st
  7. James Daniels(Center) 38th
  8. Kolton Miller (Tackle) 47th
  9. Orlando Brown (Tackle) 53rd

T.E

  1. Goedert 37th
  2. Gesicki 50th
  3. Hurst 67th

 

 

 

 

Impressive work 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


  • PMH4OWPW7JD2TDGWZKTOYL2T3E.jpg

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • You could say that-- but if we don't need a starting OT this year, why would you draft a flawed one that is not going to play? (We are coming from different underlying assumptions and perspectives--I see your argument and don't disagree with the premise) Your thinking is based on the assumption that an OT for the future is more important than immediate needs at other positions, or that we can meet other needs in later rounds even if we take the OT in round 1.  I do not think there is but 1 OT worthy of a first-round grade---they are mocked based on need and demand--if we do not have a need for a starter right now, a team at 18 may grab a T that is the 33rd best player--worth it if you have no starting T, but not if you have a starter.  So just because they are mocked around the middle of the first it does not mean that the players are good values--teams get desperate.  QBs are a great example.  Simpson may be worth it in round 1 for the Cardinals, but not the Jets, because they have Geno Smith.  Sure, they will need a QB by next year, but taking Simpson is a reach. I do not see our need, with 2 starters (Walker and Moton) and another possibly returning by the end of the season enough to justify ranking OT over positions like Safety, Will LB--I do not think we replaced A Shawn Robinson (We gonna put a NT out there?  Wharton (280lbs)?  So do we reach in round 1 for a player who may not play much or do we get a Will LB that can cover?  A deep free safety?  A quality center? A playmaking TE?  A DT to replace Robinson?  A wide receiver to balance the secondary?  Long term, if the right player was there, you would be right.  Short term, OT is a luxury at this point, in my view.  
    • Put Huey P Newton on the helmet. With his AK. 
    • We arent switching. Evero is 3-4 to the core. Given how 3-4 has been a noticeable characteristic of top defenses recently and we have drafted and signed players fir it  I dont know why anyone would think that's a good idea 
×
×
  • Create New...