About this Star v Short BS

[Doc Holiday]

Short is the better Player, pure and simple. He was the correct choice to keep if you had to pick between the two.  Anyone else besides me notice that our Defense fell apart after he went on IR? that's not a coincidence the presence that KK brought to the D-line was sorely missed the moment we lost him. Our Defense pretty much went from Elite to garbage with that one loss this season.

Star is today what he has always been, a big immovable run stuffer in the middle that gets the occasional QB pressure. His purpose has forever been to eat up 1-2 blockers and not move, and open lanes for the Linebackers. he has done nothing but that his entire career,  when your defense knows the offense isnt gonna get any push up the middle because he is there that is a great weapon to have.

Ideally we would have kept both, but we had to choose because of the Colossal mistake that was the Matt Kalil contract, which was David Gettleman's fault.  Hurney pretty much had to choose between the lesser of two evils and he chose wisely in keeping Short.

End of discussion

[(ATL'ien)CamNewton]

You had to make a third thread about it?

[Doc Holiday]

Just now, (ATL'ien)CamNewton said:

You had to make a third thread about it?

there are 3 threads about this in differing levels, this is the only opinion on this that should matter among the 3 . so yes. 

sorry you got sore butt from be destroying your topic. 

[*FreeFua*]

Of course you had to make a separate thread for your opinion. 

[Doc Holiday]

Just now, *FreeFua* said:

Of course you had to make a separate thread for your opinion. 

and still no one cares about yours, lol.

[*FreeFua*]

Just now, Doc Holiday said:

and still no one cares about yours, lol.

I assume you laugh at your own “jokes” since no one else does?

[Forty-Eight]

Short sucks!!! Star is the better player. Short is a stats player. Star is the kind of players that make everyone around him better. There’s a reason why Star was the 14th pick in the draft and would’ve went higher if not for his heart condition. Short went in the 2nd for a reason. He lived off Star’s impact on the dline and had “one”, “1”, “uno” fuggn good season!

[Forty-Eight]

22 minutes ago, Doc Holiday said:

there are 3 threads about this in differing levels, this is the only opinion on this that should matter among the 3 . so yes. 

sorry you got sore butt from be destroying your topic. 

Short sucks!!!!!

[(ATL'ien)CamNewton]

I don't think Short sucks but I think any run of the mill DT that plays the type of DT Short plays could generate Sacks playing next to Star because Star creates chaos by clogging it all up

[Doc Holiday]

4 minutes ago, Forty-Eight said:

Short sucks!!! Star is the better player. Short is a stats player. Star is the kind of players that make everyone around him better. There’s a reason why Star was the 14th pick in the draft and would’ve went higher if not for his heart condition. Short went in the 2nd for a reason. He lived off Star’s impact on the dline and had “one”, “1”, “uno” fuggn good season!

No one cares about your opinion either 48

[Doc Holiday]

23 minutes ago, *FreeFua* said:

I assume you laugh at your own “jokes” since no one else does?

I never joke, I’m always 100% serious and the internet is a super serial place! 
 

also fua it’s no secret you pretty much hate me and have for a while.

the difference between me and you is I never cared about your opinion but you care about mine. Don’t ask me why. Maybe it’s because my responses and opinions are more thought out and balanced than your general run of the mill super sensitive reactionary posts on here.

[Forty-Eight]

3 minutes ago, Doc Holiday said:

No one cares about your opinion either 48

You do dock holedey

[1of10Charnatives]

10 minutes ago, (ATL'ien)CamNewton said:

I don't think Short sucks but I think any run of the mill DT that plays the type of DT Short plays could generate Sacks playing next to Star because Star creates chaos by clogging it all up

Not to say you're wrong or you're right, but I just checked Buffalo's DT's and Jordan Phillips, drafted 2 drafts later than Short but in the same round (2) had 9.5 sacks playing next to Star this year, so there is some anecdotal evidence to support the notion. Also that's 9.5 sacks this season with a career total of 15, so getting more production this year than the rest of his career combined.

 

[(ATL'ien)CamNewton]

2 minutes ago, 1of10Charnatives said:

Not to say you're wrong or you're right, but I just checked Buffalo's DT's and Jordan Phillips, drafted 2 drafts later than Short but in the same round (2) had 9.5 sacks playing next to Star this year, so there is some anecdotal evidence to support the notion.

Short is the Peanut Butter and Jelly ..

Star is the Bread ..

Doesn't really matter if you have Peanut Butter and Jelly without the Bread