Panthers alumni answer questions about Cam Newton

[Cpt slay a ho]

4 minutes ago, Bytes said:

The statement was made Cam had a better winning percentage? Are you moving the goal post again? Keep up. 

 

Did you read ? I said playoff win percentage 

[1of10Charnatives]

Am I the only person who thinks it's weird that even though Cam played here for quite a few years, Joe Person asks 3 alumni who played with him extensively, 3 who NEVER played with him, and one guy (Gross) who played with him his first few years but retired after and has little inside perspective on Cam's time as locker room leader and vet. No offense to Wesley Walls, Moose or Frank Garcia, but I don't consider their comments on this topic super relevant.

"In a word, please tell us what a team you once played for will be like now that a player you never played with is gone."

[Bytes]

11 minutes ago, Cpt slay a ho said:

Did you read ? I said playoff win percentage 

Peyton Manning has more playoff losses than in player in NFL history. He has NINE one and dones. Is Cam a better QB than Peyton. Or, just maybe ITS A TEAM SPORT. How about Marino. Is Cam better than him? Cam has a better playoff record than him. Again I ask what individual passing stats Cam has better than any of those guys. You guys keep coming up short. Next you will be saying the concessions stands  poison Cam during the game so he couldn't perform. Its just weak the arguments you guys continue to make. 

[Cpt slay a ho]

7 minutes ago, Bytes said:

You are making stuff up. How many back to back winning seasons does he have? And I ask you what INDIVIDUAL stats Cam has (besides rushing, which is why he is broken down) that Cam has better than Ryan. For me, again, I like my QBs to be better at passing than running. You know like I like my doctors to be better at making assessments than writing prescriptions. Well maybe thats a bit too complicated for you. Matt Ryan's individual stats are waaay better than Cam's, so are Bree's, So are Wilson's, So are fill in the blank with any top 15 passing QB. 

What kind of straw man argument are you making ? That’s like not including cmc receiving yards when making a debate about who’s a better rb.

you like your qbs to better at passing, good for you, that’s your personally preference, many ways to cook a fish but your passing qbs that you like haven’t accomplished more than the rushing one you are so adamantly trying to discredit. That’s goes for Matt Stafford, Matt Ryan, Matt Damon don’t matter lol if it ain’t rodgers, Brady, Wilson Mahomes than you have a hard argument proving they’ve accomplished more cam newton. 

[Bytes]

49 minutes ago, Cpt slay a ho said:

This is trolling or you haven’t stated watching football until recently, Vick was in and out of lineups because he’d tried taking on hits like he’s was a rb.

How many seasons Vick missed because of injury? Cam? 

[Bytes]

1 minute ago, Cpt slay a ho said:

What kind of straw man argument are you making ? That’s like not including cmc receiving yards when making a debate about who’s a better rb.

you like your qbs to better at passing, good for you, that’s your personally preference, many ways to cook a fish but your passing qbs that you like haven’t accomplished more than the rushing one you are so adamantly trying to discredit. That’s goes for Matt Stafford, Matt Ryan, Matt Damon don’t matter lol if it ain’t rodgers, Brady, Wilson Mahomes than you have a hard argument proving they’ve accomplished more cam newton. 

LOL! I want to take a poll with that question. "Do you like your QB to (A) be a better passer or (B) a better runner? Hmmmmmm let me think about that one.... LOL...ridiculous. 

[Bytes]

4 minutes ago, Cpt slay a ho said:

What kind of straw man argument are you making ? That’s like not including cmc receiving yards when making a debate about who’s a better rb.

you like your qbs to better at passing, good for you, that’s your personally preference, many ways to cook a fish but your passing qbs that you like haven’t accomplished more than the rushing one you are so adamantly trying to discredit. That’s goes for Matt Stafford, Matt Ryan, Matt Damon don’t matter lol if it ain’t rodgers, Brady, Wilson Mahomes than you have a hard argument proving they’ve accomplished more cam newton. 

Its the 4th Qtr. your team is down by 5, Its 4th and 9, you want Cam or do you want any other quality passing QB..hmmm... let me think about that one....LOL!

[Bytes]

9 minutes ago, Cpt slay a ho said:

What kind of straw man argument are you making ? That’s like not including cmc receiving yards when making a debate about who’s a better rb.

you like your qbs to better at passing, good for you, that’s your personally preference, many ways to cook a fish but your passing qbs that you like haven’t accomplished more than the rushing one you are so adamantly trying to discredit. That’s goes for Matt Stafford, Matt Ryan, Matt Damon don’t matter lol if it ain’t rodgers, Brady, Wilson Mahomes than you have a hard argument proving they’ve accomplished more cam newton. 

I'm trying to find Cam Newton on this 4th Qtr comeback list. maybe my sight is going bad LOL!
 

[Cpt slay a ho]

3 minutes ago, Bytes said:

Peyton Manning has more playoff losses than in player in NFL history. He has NINE one and dones. Is Cam a better QB than Peyton. Or, just maybe ITS A TEAM SPORT. How about Marino. Is Cam better than him? Cam has a better playoff record than him. Again I ask what individual passing stats Cam has better than any of those guys. You guys keep coming up short. Next you will be saying the concessions stands  poison Cam during the game so he couldn't perform. Its just weak the arguments you guys continue to make. 

Now we gone full on matrix dodge mode, no one is comparing him to Peyton or Dan those aren’t even his peers, and Peyton proves my point lol.

its a team sport only when it benefits your narrative, but when someone mentions the WR Corp compared to your qbs you’ve listed it’s all on cam then.....pick a side of the fence.

ite name me the rushing stats those individuals have that are better than cam since we are strawmaning it up in here and running from logical conversation 

[Cpt slay a ho]

12 minutes ago, Bytes said:

How many seasons Vick missed because of injury? Cam? 

Seasons or games ? Because I don’t recall cam missing a season 

[Bytes]

1 minute ago, Cpt slay a ho said:

Now we gone full on matrix dodge mode, no one is comparing him to Peyton or Dan those aren’t even his peers, and Peyton proves my point lol.

its a team sport only when it benefits your narrative, but when someone mentions the WR Corp compared to your qbs you’ve listed it’s all on cam then.....pick a side of the fence.

ite name me the rushing stats those individuals have that are better than cam since we are strawmaning it up in here and running from logical conversation 

No its a team sport when you are talking about TEAM RECORDS. An indiviual throws, runs or catches. Clear?

[Bytes]

1 minute ago, Cpt slay a ho said:

Seasons or games ? Because I don’t recall cam missing a season 

How many games he missed last year? effectively a season. But if you want to split hairs. OK. He never missed a season... just 14 out of 16 games in a season. My bad. 

[Cpt slay a ho]

12 minutes ago, Bytes said:

LOL! I want to take a poll with that question. "Do you like your QB to (A) be a better passer or (B) a better runner? Hmmmmmm let me think about that one.... LOL...ridiculous. 

logic has slipped this one, a fair question is would you prefer a mobile qb over a traditional pocket passer.

and there’s no need for a poll look around the league, mobile qbs have taken over lol but keep living in your straw man reality    

[Bytes]

2 minutes ago, Cpt slay a ho said:

logic has slipped this one, a fair question is would you prefer a mobile qb over a traditional pocket passer.

and there’s no need for a poll look around the league, mobile qbs have taken over lol but keep living in your straw man reality    

This is a direct quote from you: "you like your qbs to better at passing, good for you, that’s your personally preference". 
Maybe its just me, but that is not a preference. Its a prerequisite.... No its not just me. Your statement was stupid.