Grade The Panthers: Bengals Game

[Skew]

Grading System: A+, A, A-, B+, ect...

Categories:

QB

RBs

WRs

OL

DL

LBs

DBs

Special Teams

Coaching

Overall

Let's see 'em.

[Black]

F.

[Skew]

QB: D+ (better than Moore, but that's not saying much; fumble)

RB: C (still blame Davidson and OL for poor performance; fumble)

WR: C+ (improvement over last week)

OL: F (these guy can't pass block or run block consistantly)

DL: C+ (better pressure for 4 quarters than last week)

LB: B (as Kurb said to me during the game, you can build a team around Beason)

DB: B+ (much improvement over last week with the INTs and coverage)

ST: B (again, better than last week; no turnovers, but no big plays either)

Coaching: D- (do I really need to make a comment?)

Overall: D-

[Hairless Cat]

fail

[bigdog10]

QB: D+ (better than Moore, but that's not saying much; fumble)

RB: C (still blame Davidson and OL for poor performance; fumble)

WR: C+ (improvement over last week)

OL: F (these guy can't pass block or run block consistantly)

DL: C+ (better pressure for 4 quarters than last week)

LB: B (as Kurb said to me during the game, you can build a team around Beason)

DB: B+ (much improvement over last week with the INTs and coverage)

ST: B (again, better than last week; no turnovers, but no big plays either)

Coaching: D- (do I really need to make a comment?)

Overall: D-

only one I disagree with is LB and DB, I believe DB should be a B- and LB should be a C (LB could not get off blocks on the screen passes)

[GameBreaker34]

http://www.charlotteobserver.com/2010/09/26/1720618/report-card.html

Darin has some grades if anyone is interested.

[JawnyBlaze]

QB - C- (Did ok, considering what he had to work with. At no moment did I slap my face and say WTF ARE YOU DOING like when Moore was in there the past two games)

RBs - C+ (Deangelo did better than the previous two games, Stewart did not.)

WRs - C (Gettis played relatively well, Lafell had 1 nice catch, but shoulda made the catch in the end zone. Smitty was Smitty when Jimmy finally started throwing him the ball)

OL - F- (Seriously Kalil, those two botched snaps were all on him....the first was up in Jimmy's chest instead of his hands, the second barely made it to Jimmy's fingertips. Blocking was terrible overall too)

DL - B- (Yay, a DLman got a sack. Decent pressure most of the night, good run defense early in the game. Broke down though.)

LBs - C+ (Anderson F'd up big on Benson's TD reception. Overall not great by the LB corps)

DBs - B (Did pretty decently against 2 elite (but aging) WRs. Had about 2 or 3 fewer INTs than they should have...)

Special Teams - B (Cosby couldn't return for poo against them, and Goodson did ok overall)

Coaching - F- (I almost want to take away the minus because they actually looked better in the second half than first, but then I remember there was only like 15 rushes in the game total and the gameplanning in general seemed to suck)

Overall - D (Overall offense looked like it has the ability to grow, but not until the O-line gets their poo straight. Maybe it's the lack of Otah, I dunno. Defense looked pretty good for the most part, considering the field position they were constantly dealing with).