Jump to content
  • Welcome!

    Register and log in easily with Twitter or Google accounts!

    Or simply create a new Huddle account. 

    Members receive fewer ads , access our dark theme, and the ability to join the discussion!

     

Throwing good money after bad: Defense


frash.exe

Recommended Posts

wrote this little piece on my blog (really honing my writing skills), anyway I'll post part of it here.

From the looks of it, this defense, to me, is stacked with talent. And if we could get someone that can bring out the full potential from these guys, and make them produce as a unit, believe me, we could end up letting them all go to FA and bringing in later round draft picks to start like some of these teams are doing. To other people, however, they can find 3 or 4 pieces of this defense to improve. DE needs 2 additions, DT needs 4 additions, we need to get a new SLB, we need to drop Lucas and get Asomugha, etc, etc. WE could throw 80% of cap space towards the defense, and it still might not be as consistent or as good as some of the more consistent defenses out there.

Lets compare and contrast, shall we? I'll use the Eagles depth chart to compare starters with the Panthers'.

LE

Tyler Brayton (1st rd drft pck; Raiders)

Juqua Parker (Undrafted; Titans)

RE

Julius Peppers (2nd ovr pck)

Trent Cole (5th rd pick)

LDT

Maake Kemoeatu (undrafted; Ravens)

Mike Patterson (1st rd pck)

RDT

Damione Lewis (1st rd pck; Rams)

Brodrick Bunkley (1st rd pck)

Linebackers

Jon Beason (1st rd pck)

Thomas Davis (1st rd pck)

Na'il Diggs (4th rd pck; Packers)

Stewart Bradley (rd 3 pck)

Akeem Jordan (undrafted)

Chris Gocong (rd 3 pck)

Secondary

Ken Lucas (2nd rd pck; Seahawks)

Chris Gamble (1st rd pck)

Chris Harris (6th rd pck; Bears)

Charles Godfrey (3rd rd pck)

Asante Samuel (4th rd pck; Pats)

Sheldon Brown (2nd rd pck)

Quintin Mikell (undrafted)

Brian Dawkins (2nd rd pck)

Carolina signs more high profile free agents, spend higher picks and more money on their defense, but they can't develop talent nearly as well as Philadelphia does, while it can be argued that Carolina invests in raw talent, it certainly didn't pay off this season when they finished 18th overall and Philly finished 3rd. Compare Beason to any Eagles LBer and he looks like a world beater. Julius Peppers gets to the QB way more often than Trent Cole. Individual comparisons would suggest that the Panthers have the more productive talent and more return in investment, but as a unit, they fail. In spite of the interceptions, the sacks, the high tackle totals, they give up a lot of yards, because it's the system they're in. Philly runs a system that works. Philly gets way more value in their players than we do, and they spend more cash on the offense, look at all the 1st day picks they've dedicated there.

In short, what I mean by "throwing good money after bad" is the fact that despite any improvements we can make in player personnel this offseason, it will be fruitless if the scheme doesn't work, and for the past 2 years at least, it definitely hasn't, and even when it did, it showed flashes of breakdowns in certain games.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I don't really agree, our linebacker corp is far better and the eagles have a lot of depth rotating in on their defensive line that comes from high (1-3) picks.

I never said their backers were better.

But also, none of their Dline depth/back ups are first round picks. Only Mike Patterson and Bunkley are, as a matter of fact, they're the only first rounders that start on their defense. Second round picks or later are in depth.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

So is this about developing talent or good scouting? Brayton and Lewis were other teams' first round picks, and both sucked where they were but are doing well enough here. Do you still want to count them as first rounders when they clearly didn't have first round value by the time we got them?

A better sense of where we are could be gotten by considering how many teams in the league our guys would start for. I think that Peppers, Gamble, Beason, and Davis would start anywhere. Kemo probably would too. Harris couldn't crack the starting lineup in Chicago, and Brayton was sliding down the depth chart in Oakland. Godfrey is a rookie, Lucas, Lewis and Diggs would start for some, but not all.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I would say that the '1st round picks' we have signed up through free agency are actually budget players. They have not lived up to their hype at all at their previous teams and thus it actually makes them cheaper than signing a player who has come on, yet was drafted in the later rounds.

Once players hit the NFL, where they were drafted means diddly squat. If you want to do this kind of thing then I would look at the players contracts, THAT is the only way to see if we are wasting money on free agents.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Philly's defense on cap hit cost around 56 million, while ours cost us about 45 million and thats counting peppers 14 million last year.

What is the total cap figure for this season? Regardless we are spending over half of our budget on offense, unless we have the most expensive special teams in the league...

Does indeed back up that recently we have looked more for the hungry over looked player rather than someone who has had a freakish season.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

What is the total cap figure for this season? Regardless we are spending over half of our budget on offense, unless we have the most expensive special teams in the league...

Does indeed back up that recently we have looked more for the hungry over looked player rather than someone who has had a freakish season.

I believe we are at 112 million, the total hit for defense is 47 million. so our offense cost us roughly 55 million. Kasay and baker count for 3.2 million combined. You also have to figure in dead space for signing bonuses for players that have been cut in the previous seasons.

Delhomme - 10 million

Gross - 7.5

Smith - 5.8

Wharton - 2.7

Dwill - 2.2

McCown - 1.9

bridges - 1.7

Stewart - 1.5

Hangartner - 1.4

Otah - 1.2

Moose - 1.2

Hoover - 1 million

Those are the offensive players that had a cap hit over 1 million With vincent being right under 1 million.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Delhomme needs to do some major restructuring, if we are going to be able to stay in the fold.

it would be difficult to make his actual salary much smaller, but not impossible but it wouldn't save us that much money.

A breakdown of his salary shows that his base salary is 3.69 million

He got a bonuses last year totaling 2.5 million

makes his actual salary 6.19 million on the season

He has a cap hit of 10.956 million for last season

His cap hit is so big from his original signing bonus and his resigning/restructuring from 2004.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

it would be difficult to make his actual salary much smaller, but not impossible but it wouldn't save us that much money.

A breakdown of his salary shows that his base salary is 3.69 million

He got a bonuses last year totaling 2.5 million

makes his actual salary 6.19 million on the season

He has a cap hit of 10.956 million for last season

His cap hit is so big from his original signing bonus and his resigning/restructuring from 2004.

What would that make his projected cap hit for next season? Ignoring any bonuses etc he may have picked up this season...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I would say that the '1st round picks' we have signed up through free agency are actually budget players. They have not lived up to their hype at all at their previous teams and thus it actually makes them cheaper than signing a player who has come on, yet was drafted in the later rounds.

Once players hit the NFL, where they were drafted means diddly squat. If you want to do this kind of thing then I would look at the players contracts, THAT is the only way to see if we are wasting money on free agents.

hypothetically speaking, one could argue the teams they were put on did not have good coaching at all.

I mean Brayton played for a team that switched head coaches every year or two. And also, wasn't Oakland's defense like top 3 one year or something like that?

Damione Lewis had 5 sacks one year in St Louis, his best total of his career, and pretty good overall for a DT.

Compare salaries you say? (top 10 for each team)

Asante Samuel(CB)$0$9,145,000

Brodrick Bunkley(DT)$0$4,014,720

Brian Dawkins(S)$0$3,340,054

Trent Cole(DE)$0$3,245,250

Darren Howard(DE)$0$3,206,720

Mike Patterson(DT)$0$3,131,250

Lito Sheppard(CB)$0$2,731,720

Sheldon Brown(CB)$0$2,381,720

Juqua Parker(DE)$0$1,806,720

Chris Clemons(LB)$0$1,500,000

34,503,154

Julius Peppers(DE)$0$14,137,500

Ken Lucas(CB)$0$5,905,000

Ma'ake Kemoeatu(DT)$0$3,545,000

Thomas Davis(LB)$0$2,196,250

Chris Gamble(CB)$0$1,983,740

Damione Lewis(DT)$0$1,913,333

Jon Beason(LB)$0$1,718,740

Landon Johnson(LB)$0$1,705,000

Tyler Brayton(LB)$0$1,525,000

Ricardo Colclough(CB)$0$1,500,000

36,129,563

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


  • PMH4OWPW7JD2TDGWZKTOYL2T3E.jpg

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Looking Back at the 2021 Panthers Draft Class An NFL player's career on average is said to last just slightly over three years, and because of that, it's considered a general rule of thumb that by Year 3, a team knows what kind of professional football player a pick has developed into. While there are always exceptions to the rule, that's not the point of this topic. This is about the players who are still on the team after being picked up in the 2021 draft (or as UDFAs). Only four remain on the roster today: Jaycee Horn, Chuba Hubbard, Tommy Tremble, and Brady Christensen. Two of them signed significant contract extensions with the team (Horn, Hubbard) while the other two (Tremble, Christensen) received short-term deals that aren't cap-heavy. It's worth mentioning the conditions these guys entered the league under Matt Rhule's second year and Scott Fitterer's first. A ton of players were brought in that year, including a long snapper who didn't make the team… instead of Trey Smith, who just happens to be the Chiefs' starting guard (hey... to be fair to Thomas Fletcher, he did have a fun draft day phone call). These four survived Rhule and Reich and were seen as valuable enough under the first-year combo of Morgan and Canales to be rewarded with second deals. Jaycee Horn (Round 1, Pick 8.) Horn has all of the traits of a true CB1: elite footwork, physicality, and the ability to mirror WR1s... but his biggest challenge has been staying on the field. He's never finished an entire season, though to be fair, it's been rumored he wouldn’t have been shut down for the final two weeks of last season had the team been in playoff contention. He's got just 37 career games played over four seasons (with 15 of those coming in Morgan/Canales' Year 1). The team gambled on his production after seeing that not only can he lock down WR1s in man or match quarters, but he can also be dependable in a heavy cover-3 zone scheme like what the Panthers ran last season. With the recent free agent and draft additions made this offseason, expect Jaycee to go back to eliminating WR1s from the game rather than shutting down a third of the field like he was recently asked to do. Chuba Hubbard (Round 4, Pick 126) Originally seen as a depth pick with linear speed, Hubbard has outperformed expectations and emerged as the team's RB1 over the past couple of years. His 2023 breakout laid the foundation, but in 2024 he cemented his role as the lead back, showing much-improved vision, contact balance, and decisiveness in outside zone. He finished top-10 in missed tackles forced and yards after contact per attempt, all while holding his own in pass protection and producing on screens. Chuba doesn't have elite burst or wiggle, but he's carved out a spot as the leader and tone-setter in the run game. Not bad value for a Day 3 selection—positional value be damned. Tommy Tremble (Round 3, Pick 83) Tremble has been the kind of player every team needs but few talk about: dependable, physical, and quietly versatile. When he was drafted, he was already known for his blocking chops and has steadily improved as a receiver. He experienced his most complete season in 2024 with a 79.3% catch rate, 10.2 yards per reception, no drops, and a 108.9 passer rating when targeted. Not only that, he's been a consistent special teamer since coming into the league. He's a natural fit as a TE/FB hybrid in 12 and 13 personnel, consistently handling the dirty work in both run and pass situations. Brady Christensen (Round 3, Pick 70) BC has played all over the line both as a starter and as a back-up. We haven't seen the "short arms" come up as often as Rhule was worried about, especially against ATL and WAS where he logged over 100 snaps at center and posted his best grades of the year (76.0 OVR, 73.8 PBL, 75.8 RBLK vs. ATL; 85.2 OVR, 72.9 PBLK, 86.0 RBLK vs. WAS). While his overall pass-blocking grade (56.1) and lack of a consistent position might mean that he's the perfect OL6 rather than a long-term starter, he's been dependable when given his opportunities.
    • Fees nowadays are ridiculous. After purchasing concert tickets for my son’s 18th birthday and paying the rest of our HHI trip with 3 other families, I’m shocked at how much they are. Honestly, it’s grand theft. Some is taxes but in a world where everything is electronic, fees should be cheaper. Electrons don’t cost 10-30% of the event.
×
×
  • Create New...