American Idol

[rodeo]

Why do they call Thia out for being safe, but let Scotty sing the same song every week?

[sunbunny]

I liked Thia tonight.

[Dpantherman]

I forgot Casey Abrams could actually sing, because he is usually jumping around. thank you sir!!! this is great

[sunbunny]

He may have saved himself tonight. I think this was his best.

[Dpantherman]

DAMN Jacob

[rodeo]

Haley is so awesome.

[sunbunny]

I think Haley has the sexiest voice of all the girls.

[Dpantherman]

well, Hailey has my attention. 'Bennie and the Jets' is one of my all time favorites. I was expecting to here circle of life tonight...but anyway I thought that was awesome.

Paul was my least favorite, he and Naimi should be in the bottom.

[rodeo]

I would send Stefano home this week. Seemed like he didn't 'get' the song, pretty weak vocals.

[Dpantherman]

I agree, but I think he was better than Paul.

Overall, this is one the best groups Idol has had in a while. After tomorrow night its going to get really really tight.

[rodeo]

Paul is local to me so I hope he sticks around. He'd be better off doing his own thing though, American Idol isn't the place for him.

[Seal (SmittyIsOurSavior)]

As solid a night as Idol has ever had.

[sunbunny]

Naimi and Stefano should go.

I'll admit, I'm actually voting tonight for Haley.

[Seal (SmittyIsOurSavior)]

Sh*t, I'm so bored, I'll go through them all.

1. Scotty - Definitely not his best, but he will without a doubt be a country star in a few years.

2. Naima - She's done. Although it was different and interesting, it wasn't near enough to stand out tonight. Buh bye.

3. Paul - Very good performance for him. His voice may not be a fit for Idol, but I think he can make it big in his respective niche. Very solid tonight.

4. Pia - She does the same sh*t every week, but I will admit that she has f*cking talent. I see her being a little like Mariah was in the 90's.

5. Stefano - He is my personal favorite in the competition. Vocally, he is incredible. He is so underrated, probably because he had two horrible performances earlier this season. He brings it again and again since then, though. Fantastic.

6. Lauren - For me, her best so far. I really like how she slowed it down a bit and just straight sand the song.

7. James - Vocally, not his best. Probably his worse. BUT he could put on one mad concert, and that's part of what being a star is.

8. Thia - Very good singing from her. People may argue she's a bit boring, which is true, but she can definitely sing as well as anyone in this competition. Beautiful performance.

9. Casey - I liked how he showed his softer side. Now, his vocals were a bit off here and their, but it was pretty good.

10. Jacob - Jeezums he can sing. I can imagine all the Southern Baptists voting for him right now. He may not be Idol material because his sh*t isn't mainstream, but he's got a huge voice.

11. I wouldn't say it was easily the best of the night, but she's easily my favorite girl. It was really good, and sexy as usual.

That was a damn solid episode. Too bad they're all packed into the same season. Almost anyone from this season could've killed the last 2 or 3 seasons.

I think Naima and Stefano are done. What a shame though, cause Stefano has some killer talent. I'd buy his album any day.