clady,otah,williams,and albert

[PantherBrew]

Overall--CLADY>OTAH

Run Blocking--OTAH>>CLADY

Pass Blocking --CLADY>>OTAH

Potential OTAH=CLADY

Both perfect rookie lineman, for their respective offenses.

[charlottenian]

It's a silly debate.... both are excellent Rookies..... both will be playing in multiplel Probowls to come

[Orange Habit]

yea, we know. he said otah is new to football, because he didnt start playing til his senior year in highschool. he is still learning basic fundamentals of the game. no-where to go but up with him.

Clady played defensive tackle in high school, and was slated to do so at BSU until the coaches got the brilliant idea of switching him over. So Clady's also green at the position, as well.

That being said, it's a real silly thing to argue about, because both Clady and Otah obviously have natural talent and are tremendous athletes, and they would fit on a football field eventually, no matter what.

[SKULL]

..I remember we faced albert in the k.c game but dont remeber him being good or bad..

Albert had a great day against the PANTHERS

He was out that game !!

[panther4life]

Albert had a great day against the PANTHERS

He was out that game !!

wel that explains me not remebering anything about his perfomance

[PowerlessDan]

I am very happy with the one we got and the pick we got him at.

[Kaylore]

Ryan Clady is starting and having a pro-bowl season at LT. Otah is a RT and while having a good year, isn't anywhere near as good as Clady's. LT > RT. In fact even if Otah had the same number of sacks allowed and success rate in the running game playing at LT, Clady would still be better. If Otah moves over to the blind side then we'll see, but it's not even close.

[Stalkerfishy]

Does anyone know how many sacks Otah has let up?

Clady has .5

But it was that odd call in the San Diego game

[gcver2ver3]

Overall--CLADY>OTAH

Run Blocking--OTAH>>CLADY

Pass Blocking --CLADY>>OTAH

Potential OTAH=CLADY

you were doing good until that last part...

why does Otah have more potential than Clady?...

they're both rookies that are still learning....

edit: nevermind...i misread your post...

my bad...

[Kaylore]

Does anyone know how many sacks Otah has let up?

Clady has .5

But it was that odd call in the San Diego game

Otah has allowed 5 sacks this season.

[Ncstatefan]

It's a silly debate.... both are excellent Rookies..... both will be playing in multiplel Probowls to come

Amen

[cutler7624]

clady may be the best right now but otah is pretty new to football. once he learns more and gets more experience he is going to be elite at RT or LT.

Clady came into Boise St. as a defensive tackle and never played offensive line all through high school. He left college after his Jr. season and this is only his 4th year playing the LT position.:eek:

[Woodie]

Ryan Clady is starting and having a pro-bowl season at LT. Otah is a RT and while having a good year, isn't anywhere near as good as Clady's. LT > RT. In fact even if Otah had the same number of sacks allowed and success rate in the running game playing at LT, Clady would still be better. If Otah moves over to the blind side then we'll see, but it's not even close.

Now that is just homeristic and ignorant. Look, both are quality Tackles that have completely different roles on their respective teams, as well as having different strengths and weaknesses. Clady, no doubt, is the better pass blocker, but just the same, Otah is clearly the better run blocker (although neither is bad at the other). And for our team's philosophy, the run blocker plays a more important role, so is the more valuable skill set.

[Woodie]

Otah has allowed 5 sacks this season.

Playing all season on a high ankle sprain he received in the first game, which has limited his lateral mobility. So sack numbers for him are very misleading.