Jump to content

  • Welcome!

    Register and log in easily with Twitter or Google accounts!

    Or simply create a new Huddle account. 

    Members receive fewer ads , access our dark theme, and the ability to join the discussion!

     

Pat Ranks NFC South Linemen

TerriblePizza

By TerriblePizza,
in Carolina Panthers

Recommended Posts

TerriblePizza Newbie

TerriblePizza

Posted
Posted

http://myespn.go.com/blogs/nfcsouth/0-12-19/Ranking-the-NFC-South-offensive-linemen.html

We've completed the quarterbacks, running backs, tight ends and wide receivers in our NFC South position ratings. Now, it's time for the offensive linemen. We're not breaking them into different positions, but are considering the premium placed on left tackles, the most important people on the offensive line.

1. Jordan Gross, Carolina. He finally got All-Pro recognition last year as the Panthers returned to coach John Fox's ball-control offense.

2. Jeff Faine, Tampa Bay. A case can be made he's the best center in the league. He's also the leader of a very good offensive line.

3. Todd McClure, Atlanta. Go ahead and argue all you want about their underrated center. The Falcons ran the ball and protected rookie Matt Ryan very well last year. It had to start somewhere. It started with McClure.

4. Davin Joseph, Tampa Bay. The Bucs have been building the interior of their line for several seasons and it looks like they've got it right with Joseph and Faine.

5. Jammal Brown, New Orleans. Not as dominant as Gross, but he's got the Pro Bowl on his resume and has kept Drew Brees standing.

6. Donald Penn, Tampa Bay. Fire away on this one. I know the rule of thumb is you get your left guard in the first round. Penn's far from dominant, but so are a lot of tackles who were taken in the first round. He's become a solid, reasonably-priced player at a key position.

7. Jeff Otah, Carolina. One single move allowed Fox to return to his ball-control system. That was drafting Otah, a natural mauler and placing him at right tackle.

8. Jahri Evans, New Orleans. This guy has started all 48 games in four years and almost never makes a mistake.

9. Sam Baker, Atlanta. His status as a left tackle taken in the first round is a little shaky because of injury problems last year. But, if Baker comes back healthy, he could be in the top five.

10. Travelle Wharton, Carolina. I'm giving Wharton a very slight nod of New Orleans guard Carl Nicks, who had a very nice rookie season. Another season like that and Nicks will move ahead. But I'm keeping Wharton right now for his versatility and heady play.

I'd argue that our linemen should be much higher. Tampa Bay has way too many in the top half.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
TerriblePizza Newbie

TerriblePizza

Posted
  • Author
Posted

Move everyone up one spot take out Baker and put in Ryan Kalil

So TB and ATLs center is that much better than ours??? A bit laughable but hell its an opinion poll....

I agree that Faine is a good center, but its arguable that he's the best in our division.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
monstercat Newbie

monstercat

Posted
Posted

I still believe Baker is and will be a bust.

I wouldn't say that. He was pretty good when he was in there. Missing so much time with that back injury should put him down the list though.

Also, I would put Kalil up there with any center in the south, and he's just getting started.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
CarolinaPanthers8789 Newbie

CarolinaPanthers8789

Posted
Posted

Well if you picked out of the remaining offensive linemen for the Panthers who would you put on the list and who would you take off.

Panthers Linemen

G- Mackenzy Bernadeau

T- Patrick Brown

T- Gerald Cadogan

G- C.J. Davis

G- Justin Geisinger

C- Keith Gray

T- Jordan Gross

C- Ryan Kalil

T- Jeff Otah

T- Jonathan Palmer

G- Duke Robinson

T- Geoff Schwartz

G- Keydrick Vincent

G- Travelle Wharton

T- Gary Williams

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Go to topic listing

  • PMH4OWPW7JD2TDGWZKTOYL2T3E.jpg

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • strato
      QBs that would cost next to nothing and are better than anything we currently have.

      By strato · Posted

      I am no football savant as has been demonstrated here over and over, but I saw it.  I went for years doing the mock draft thing and researching the players that we might get around our pick, time consuming stuff. And we would get to the draft and trade the pick. All that time, wasted.  So I quit doing that. Also realized I was not a scout and would never be a scout and went to looking the videos and reports After  we picked a guy.  Maybe I would look at the 1st round, but quit that too and just looked after we picked.    When they did that trade I saw Bryce and his size and just ruled him out. Then it got to yeah they are probably going to take him, I relented and looked at some video and got to his pro day. It took me all of a few minutes to see the issues. The footwork. The arm. And the tape of games? The backyard style. I knew, what can I say?  (Also, went down the physical checklist, not a single plus attribute on the NFL level. Arm, speed, size, etc, nothing to offset the negatives. nothing)  I think it was easy for me because I had not watched a single game he played in college,and wasn’t drawn in by the hype. Had no preconceived notions and just looked at it pretty clinically.  I got in here and everyone was going “but look at what he did in college! It is the SEC, if he can do it in the SEC he can do it in the NFL!” Couldn’t reason with hardly anyone.  I don’t think I could tell you which guy would succeed between two prototypical guys with great arms and athleticism, and have no special insight into any of that. My one calling in football scouting was to see the real about what we were about to do. And you still don’t know for sure until they get in a real game in the NFL. 
    • kungfoodude
      Bills predictions

      By kungfoodude · Posted

      Miss Bryce sorely is possibly the most hilarious statement I have read on the Huddle in quite some time.
    • kungfoodude
      QBs that would cost next to nothing and are better than anything we currently have.

      By kungfoodude · Posted

      He did only throw 1 pass 20+ in that game. I think he is still struggling to adjust to the NFL. At Alabama he was able to extend plays and play backyard football. That's not only not the style of offense we have been running but his physical skills don't lend themselves to that style of play at this level.  So, the amount of issues he actually has to clean up are WAAAAAY more than I anticipated as a guy that had Bryce #1 on my board in that draft class.  I am just not seeing a reasonable path for him to clean it all up and develop in a reasonable timeframe 
×
×
  • Create New...