X-Clown

He was genuinely questionable in week 1 with an ankle injury, maybe it’s possible that led to his slow start?

It’s saying something that we are four pages in and there’s not a single mention of the Ian Thomas extension.

It certainly helped Trevor Lawrence

Are you saying that Reich would have preferred signing Carr over drafting a QB?

Not a fan of giving up more draft capital for a coach. We need to rebuild

Rumors are Eberflus is gone if he loses Thursday night

Puka Nacua

God no.

I think you’ve got some revisionist history. This is the only thread I could find, but I don’t see many mad people at the time about him leaving. I only wish I could the thread when he was named interim GM and they were considering keeping him full time, that one was full meltdown.

Now to be fair, can you name a single person who at the time would have been excited for us to promote Brandon Beane, who had spent his entire career working under Marty Hurney who we couldn't wait to get rid of? I remember that being idea being completely torn to shreds when it was floated by Gantt or whoever that it was a strong consideration because it would have just been more of the same.

I think we are probably getting ahead of ourselves with thinking that Reich is gone this early. But I'll play along and throw out a name that interested me during the last cycle that I think is going to be a popular choice in this cycle and that is Shane Waldron, the OC of Seattle. A young offensive mind that has worked under Belichick and McVay and since becoming OC has managed to resurrect the career of Geno Smith who everyone believed was just going to drive Seattle to tank for a QB. They lost in Week one to the Rams when both of their starting tackles got hurt, but then I believe they played without both of them at the Lions in Week 2 and put up 30 points on offense and beat what seems to be one of the more complete teams in the NFC. Drew Lock managed to even look functional in limited action (the only other time that happened was when he played against Rhule and co. in 2020). I'd be good with Ben Johnson, but he already spurned us once. Bienemy would also be near the top of my want list too.

I'd imagine that it has to be much deeper than just Bryce's first 3 games of development

Always crickets when this question comes up

I already signed that for better or worse when I started following this team almost 30 years ago. Can't see switching teams now or ever - if the team were moved outside of the Carolinas, I might just not have a team anymore.

They were out in masses in 2021 also. I've heard that they travel pretty well to road games in warmer climates in October since it's already miserable and cold up there.

This. I'm pretty sure I dropped an F bomb without thinking after the Bryce fumble which I don't know if other people overheard since the sea of Vikings fans I was in were around me were cheering. But that's a lot different than who is yelling it five times in every sentence and getting worse throughout the game.

If this is really true, why did he sign Bridgewater to a 3 year deal for starter’s money a month before the draft if he wanted to trade up to get Herbert?

To be fair, S2 was getting press because Brock Purdy scored super high on it and led 2022’s class, and a lot of elite QBs like Mahomes, Burrow, Allen, and Brees scored really high on it too. But totally agree that it’s one data point that shouldn’t be the end all be all, just like the idea that we shouldn’t have drafted stroud because durrr there’s no good Ohio state QBs in the NFL.

Yeah I’m used to seeing at least a few cowboys and Steelers jerseys every week. I’ve even seen The Golden Calf of Bristol broncos jerseys before - just really bizarre choice with the jaguars/urban Meyer era as a tight end where he didn’t even make the team

Imagine coming to a Panthers-Vikings game and wanting to showcase the illustrious run that The Golden Calf of Bristol had with the Jaguars when Urban Meyer let him “play” tight end in the preseason

Another depressing game at the bank but at least this gave me a chuckle

But I was told you can’t be a good QB if you played for Ohio state?

The funny part is so many people on this board Cam’s rookie season were criticizing him “because his stats are pretty but he’s just not a leader and doesn’t win games like te bow and dalton”. I am glad people finally are appreciating what we had back then

Why do you keep bringing up Metcalf? Seattle just paid him last off-season and has no reason to trade him.

Pick would have been forgivable if you’re a team like the niners or eagles who are pretty stacked all around and can take a chance that he would develop on the bench. Or if he were a 6th or 7th round pick, but not a trade up in the 3rd. Just a baffling pick all around.