ForJimmy

I’m good with trading back and I’m also good with BPA

This is accurate but 1st round QBs have a higher chance of being good. Rodgers, Allen, Tua, Jackson, Burrow, Stroud, Lawrence, Mahomes, Herbert, (possibly Daniels), Goff, Love, Darnold, Baker, Murray, and Stafford were all 1st rounders. Which is 16 of the current starters and are decent QBs. That doesn't include Williams, Nix, Maye, Richardson and Penix who the jury is still out on. The problem is they will always be overdrafted, so you have to find a real diamond in the rough to get one later. Yeah a lot of these guys have switched from their original teams, but they are all talented QBs drafted in the first round.

The wives knows their poo

The value of his investment is growing every year. Yeah he wants to win, but I don't think he is as miserable as everyone thinks he is about it. The best for us fans is for him to find something that works and get lucky with a GM/HC hire like the 49ers owner did.

All of that plus the punt block.

Mrs Rhule was great at drafting…

I think we only get the comp based on how many FAs we sign. With out roster, I'd assume we sign enough FAs to not get a comp for any player we let walk.

I believe Tepper wanted Fields in the draft

Oh I agree he is still pretty raw, but you said he wasn’t the QB coach of either QB. I was just saying that was his job title when Geno signed with Seattle.

I believe he was Seattle’s QB Coach during Geno’s comeback year in 2022. He was the passing game coordinator the years prior. People are shying away from his ability to help QBs because he can’t help Bryce so quickly. Maybe Bryce just can’t be helped?

Howell isn’t a FA and Fields is. Howell would be a good one to look at if he was, but I’m game for signing Fields this offseason if the price is right.

You love some TMac! I think we do defense with our first, but I’d be good with TMac. I haven’t seen a WR his size move like that in a while.

He is 25 years old and I think he has had a different OC every year. I don’t think he has hit his ceiling yet.

I think he played for Buffalo later but couldn’t ever get back to form.

To be fair, KB struggled after his mom passed. He never really recovered. I feel bad for him…

He has 10 TDs to 1 INT on the year and is 4-2. If Russ can do better than that more power to him.

Right. Plus Fields has a lot more potential than 36 year old Dalton.

Also no I wouldn’t trade any draft picks for anyone. I’d do the opposite. If someone offers a decent pick for a player, they can have it. I’m not against signing Fields in the offseason without having to give up anything as he is a free agent. He can be a good bridge QB who still has potential.

lol I was thinking there is no way he is suggesting what I think. You got me on it. Good one!

Again we had to pass to open up the run. You can’t just do one without the other. The YPA for Chuba was in the low 3s through most of the first half. We started connecting on passes and the defense had to back up.

I guess it all about perspective. I feel like our 24 class looks decent so far. Wallace is setting records for rookie tackles, XL is looking better than I thought at this point and already has a couple TDs, Coker is actually showing ability. I'd assume Brooks will be a decent RB because that's a pretty safe position, but I know what assuming can do. The average draft class has 1 maybe 2 players get 2nd contracts. We already have several flashing some ability.

The right moves and we are a few years away. You can paint it however you want. Obviously if we make bad moves it takes longer, but teams in today's NFL can flip it pretty quick. It starts with XL, Coker, Wallace, and Brooks developing and giving us some foundation. We also need our top pick this year to be a success. We need BPA and he needs to some a franchise cornerstone. That should be expected in the top 5 which is where we are drafting.

The decision is what makes the throw bad lol. I don't mean the physical throw was wabbly or weak but it was a bad decision thus a bad throw. You can see Terrell right in front of Thomas (not Sanders my bad) plus I believe a safety was right behind him. I see 4 white jerseys all around a TE who can't even catch the ball regardless and it completely blanketed by Terrell. It's a bad throw... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XjuIHuCypEo

No team is 5 plus years away. You can build a decent roster in 3 years, but you need to draft right and be smart with your FA signings. The Texans did it fast as did the Lions recently.

You need a good defense for that style of ball. Both of them like to lean on their defense. Our defense is complete ass right now... Both are solid coaches but we don't have to players to do what they do yet.