smith or reggie wayne

[GODFREE]

I am in a keeper fantasy league and It is hard not to be biased when picking players. anyway I have reggie wayne got him as a 2nd pick, someone wants to trade me straight up for steve smith. I know peyton is ridiculous and they are a throw first team. where as panthers being a run first team throws less. One not biased would say this was an easy pick (wayne) but I love smitty, like man crush love. anyone want to offer there opinion. and yes I am retarded. :sifone::sifone::sifone:

[JSouth]

Hard choice there. I think we will be throwing more than we want to this year. I hope our D will look better than what I have seen so far but if they don't we might be playing ketchup

[LelouchBritannia]

I think wayne has only had more yards than smitty twice, 04 and 07.But that was as a no 2 receiver....i'd say keep wayne tbh.

[DelhommesTheMan]

I had this pick yesterday between SMith and Wayne, and I went with Smith...he's just targeted like crazy by Jake...Peyton throws all over the place, Clark, Gonzalez. It will be decently close im assuming but i think SMith edges out Wayne stat wise..Atleast thats what the trend is..

[rayzor]

peyton loves throwing to gonzalex. says he can throw to him with his eyes closed because he knows where gonzlaez is where he is supposed to be.

going to be seeing a lot of peyton to gonazalez this year. that's the only thing i would worry about with wayne. jake is throwing to the TEs more this year and he ahs another couple good receiving options in moore and goodson. is he going to be using all of that consistently or sticking with 89?

toss up right there. flip a coin. i'd more likely go with smith but it's going to be close. smith isn't likely to fall down on the 1 as much as he did last year.

[TheRealDeal]

I would take Smith if its a PPR league because he gets more of those hitches and what not but even if it isn't its going to be close with them. Even missing two games last year he had 2nd most yds in the league I believe. But the Colts aren't going to have much of a running game this year and Wayne is the #1 there so he could see his #s improve without Marvin or Addai having a good season. I guess I would take Smith just because he gets targeted so much and can do so much after he gets the ball in his hands, triple covered or not!

[KillerKat]

I'd definately go with Wayne.

[SCpanther]

I don't think it's an easy choice at all. I'd give a slight edge to Wayne because he'll probably have more TDs. I think Smitty will have more yards but his TD numbers have gone down each year since 2005. I don't see him having more than 6-8 TDs with our running game taking the bulk of them.

[rayzor]

fwiw i have both of them dead even in catches, smith having a slight edge in yardage (within 50 yards) and wayne with one more TD.

footballguys.com has smith ranked a bit higher. wayne's ADP is a couple spots earlier.

[hdevonxz]

are you trying to win?

[GODFREE]

Took Smitty, let you know how it works out

Rodgers, Aaron QB GB CHI

Johnson, Chris RB TEN

Stewart, Jonathan RB CAR

Bowe, Dwayne WR KC

Wayne, Reggie WR IND/ smitty

Witten, Jason TE DAL

Kasay, John K CAR

Giants DST

Favre, Brett QB MIN

Coffee, Glen RB SF

Parker, Willie RB PIT

Williams, Cadillac RB TB

Chambers, Chris WR SD @OAK

Muhammad, Muhsin WR CAR PHI

Ward, Hines WR PIT

Panthers DST

[rayzor]

you will start parker more than stewart. tomlin just said that parker is the featured back and will be getting the largest part of the load.