Matt Moore = 1st Rd Qualifying Offer

[LaChance87]

Waiting to see how he plays next year and trading him away for picks are two very different things. I'd venture to say that most of the people who want to keep Moore here -- myself included -- are not ready to sign him to a long-term contract just yet. We'll wait until he bombs his first playoff game to do that.

Go back and see if I ever said I agree to trade him away for a draft pick, if you'd read all of my comments you'd notice the first one say I agree he did good and deserves a shot for the starting job in camp next year, just dont see how everyones sold him... so get your facts straight before you call someone out.

[LaChance87]

Yeah and didnt show much promise in that game as far a the quarterback of the future.

[Kettle]

is it really this hard to use the quote feature?

wk 1 Matt was 6/11 for 63 yds and an int. the guy had not been getting starter snaps in camp. he had little to no chemistry with even the center let alone the rest of the team. i think he did farely well given the circumstance.

[CRA]

Yeah and didnt show much promise in that game as far a the quarterback of the future.

Jake came in after the half down by 17

Moore was the 3rd QB and came in during the 4th down by 21

I don't know how hard it is to realize that two scenarios are not the same.

Moore came in when a game was in fact OVER. He was playing with a bunch of guys mentally done for the day. Moore looked in 09 just like the guy in 07 when given a start.

[LaChance87]

Thats all in your opinion... for all we know the guys Delhomme was playing with were mentally done and because he has such great leadership he turned them around. I like matt moore, i have nothing against him never said i wanted him to go, I dont think he's worth a first rounder, and I said he derserves a shot at the starting job. Doing good the last five games of the season just doesnt sell him on him, two of the teams had the playoffs locked up, and i know favre stayed in the whole game. But that vikings team and a team at the begining of the season would play at two differnt levels.

[Mr. Scot]

Matt's a gamer. I'm not saying he's the end all for our QB options, but he certainly needs to be retained for the shot. Try and draft another if the timing is right draftwise to hedge in case Delhomme's time is running out as it appears it might be, but keep Moore in the fold, he's a gamer...

Who let you in? :sosp:

(hey Mint; long time no see)

[Argus Plexus]

If you would trade Matt Moore, you're a bigger idiot than anyone on the current coaching staff. Steve Beuerline was our best QB, and pre-2009 Jake takes second. But Matt Moore has the potential to become the Panthers's best QB ever.

[CharlotteBeer.com]

Go back and see if I ever said I agree to trade him away for a draft pick, if you'd read all of my comments you'd notice the first one say I agree he did good and deserves a shot for the starting job in camp next year, just dont see how everyones sold him... so get your facts straight before you call someone out.

Not calling you out, I just thought your comments might have had something to do with trading Matt away for picks, which is the topic at hand. Or at least it was, until we all started arguing with each other.

:cheers2:

[Mr. Scot]

My belief is that Moore will get the second round tender. I know a lot of folks will be upset if that happens, but honestly it's reasonable. If it's the first round offer, I won't complain. I just don't think that's what it'll be.

Everything I've read indicates he's got no intention of looking elsewhere and I seriously doubt the Panthers are looking at trading him (nor should they).

[CRA]

Thats all in your opinion... for all we know the guys Delhomme was playing with were mentally done and because he has such great leadership he turned them around. I like matt moore, i have nothing against him never said i wanted him to go, I dont think he's worth a first rounder, and I said he derserves a shot at the starting job. Doing good the last five games of the season just doesnt sell him on him, two of the teams had the playoffs locked up, and i know favre stayed in the whole game. But that vikings team and a team at the begining of the season would play at two differnt levels.

sorry, there is simply a difference between being down 17 at halftime and being down 21 into the 4th quarter. It is called time. Moore is 6-2 as a starter.....only one of those 8 teams had a losing record. He should compete for the job next year with someone not named Jake.

[Kettle]

Thats all in your opinion... for all we know the guys Delhomme was playing with were mentally done and because he has such great leadership he turned them around. I like matt moore, i have nothing against him never said i wanted him to go, I dont think he's worth a first rounder, and I said he derserves a shot at the starting job. Doing good the last five games of the season just doesnt sell him on him, two of the teams had the playoffs locked up, and i know favre stayed in the whole game. But that vikings team and a team at the begining of the season would play at two differnt levels.

Seeding still wasn't set at wk 15, and the viking still had a shot at #1. please DON"T try again.

[LaChance87]

Not calling you out, I just thought your comments might have had something to do with trading Matt away for picks, which is the topic at hand. Or at least it was, until we all started arguing with each other.

:cheers2:

Yeah, I know it, I'm going to say I know the draft is where you get the talent from but to be honest I'd rather have a proven vet back there rather than going after an unproven rookie, cause you have the risk of getting a bust. Thats why i'm not mad we dont have a first rounder this year because you find a dimond in rough in later rounder for cheaper. My point was in my opinion he's not worth a first rounder, because we havent even seen him in a full season... all we have seen is a few games and are going on some promision stats. The original poster was comparing his december stats to that of peyton manning which is inacurate because Peyton sorta had half of december off. Dont get me wrong I like Moore, and I hope he is the answer and as of now judging from what I saw towards the end of the season, he's our best choice at QB position. But I have my doubts, because of my lack of opportunity of seeing in more games.

[LaChance87]

Seeding still wasn't set at wk 15, and the viking still had a shot at #1. please DON"T try again.

They were in the playoff, they knew it, yeah i'm sure they would have loved to be the #1 seed but they knew they were getting there. You dont think the teams were playing harder at the start of the season? With the playoffs not even in sight?

[LaChance87]

sorry, there is simply a difference between being down 17 at halftime and being down 21 into the 4th quarter. It is called time. Moore is 6-2 as a starter.....only one of those 8 teams had a losing record. He should compete for the job next year with someone not named Jake.

Okay