So where would you put Steve Smith on your top ten list of receivers?

[Carolina Panther Lou]

Me personally number 3. Number two goes to Moss and number one is The greatest of all time Jerry Rice.

[Ricky Spanish]

i can't agree with you there.

maybe he's a top 10 receiver in the league RIGHT NOW, but no where near the top 5 all time.

1a andre johnson

1b larry fitzgerald

2 Reggie Wayne

3 Moss

4 Brandon Marshall

5 Ochocinco

6 Smitty

not sure about the rest, bolden, Calvin Johnson, ward, driver, TO, and welker are all somewhere in there too, i don't feel like ranking anyone after smitty though.

[Kurb]

Smitty is better than Wayne and Ochocinco.

At this point in their careers you could argue he is better than Moss.

Johnson/Fitz/Marshall lead the pack now IMO.

[Carolina Panther Lou]

You kno what you are right, but I wouldn't say Larry is top 5 that's for sure.

[theyhateme45]

Wow... I thought you were talking about top 10 currently, not top 10 of all time. Currently I would argue somewhere between 4-6.

[Swarly]

Current active players:

1A: Andre Johnson

1B: Fitzy

3: Megatron

4: Brandon Marshall

5: Randy Moss

6: Smitty

7: Reggie Wayne

8: Ochocinco

9: Vincent Jackson

10: Sidney Rice

now this list is just off the top of my head. I've got a brutal headache from all the damn pollen in my area now, so I know I'm forgetting someone or I put someone in the wrong place. the way I see it though, is Fitz and Andre are on a whole different level from all other receivers, and the rest are for the most part interchangeable based on individual opinions.

I will say that out of all of those receivers; Smitty, Brandon Marshall, and Megatron(Calvin Johnson for those who don't know) all have average to below average quarterbacks(or worse..) throwing them the ball. Moss, Fitz, Wayne, and Rice have future HOF'ers throwing them the ball, and V-Jax has Rivers who is a top 5 QB.

I love making these kinds of lists so I'll definitely be back to edit and look at others.

[coxc63]

1.Andre Johnson

2.Larry Fitzgerald

3.Steve Smith

4.Randy Moss

5.Brandon Marshall

5.Calvin Johnson (He's elite and plays on a sorry team)

6.Reggie Wayne

7.Chad Ochocinco

8.Roddy White

9.Wes Welker

10.Anquan Bolden

Steve is arguably the greatest "Smith" of all time. (It's a toss up between him and Emmitt Smith IMO)

[DeAngelo Beason]

It's unfortunate because if Steve Smith had Peyton Manning as a quarterback, I have 0% doubt that he would have already posted multiple 2,000 yard receiving seasons. I think he's the greatest physical talent ever at wide receiver given his size, speed, strength, and jumping ability. The only thing he's ever slightly lacked was route running, which is by no means sub par, and he more than makes up for it with his other remarkable abilities.

[DynastyRTR]

1a-Andre Johnson

1b-Larry Fitzgerald

3-Steve Smith

4-Reggie Wayne

5-Brandon Marshall

6-Randy Moss

7-Megatron

8-Ochocinco

9-Roddy White

10-Anquan Boldin

[Carolina Panther Lou]

Ok so that's three of us that said SMITTY Number 3 I just think for his size he is great just watch and see the numbers he puts of if Matt starts!!!!

[OneBadassCat]

Larry is over hyped. Steve would blow his numbers away if he played for the cardinals. Think about all the things that go against Steve's game and compare that to the other top WR's in this league. One thing you will notice is that they all have top 10 QBs.

[Jase]

about 14 or 15.

[Carolina Panther Lou]

Amen you have said it and nailed it right on Steve would blow Larry away. All it takes is one good pop and Larry's career would be over!

[Seal (SmittyIsOurSavior)]

1. Andre Johnson

2. Fitz (It will be interesting to see how he does without Kurt)

3. Smitty

4. Wes Welker

5. Miles Austin

6. Vincent Jackson

7. Reggie Wayne

8. Desean Jackson

9. Randy Moss

10. Sidney Rice