Randy Moss.....best ever (besides Rice)

[mywinke]

I love SS, but.......

I'm not a huge Moss fan, but these are some compelling stats.

http://www.nflstatanalysis.net/2010/06/how-good-is-randy-moss.html

[Sandy Claws]

BS

WHy didn't the author show the improvement in the Raiders' QBs while Moss was there? Maybe because there was none?

The reality is that he started with a team with a decent QB, a decent running game, and quality on the other end of the line (Minnesota with Cunningham, George, Culpepper as QBs, Smith as RB and HOFer CArter as WR). He went to Oakland where he had crap and performed like it, then landed in NE with Brady, a decent committe of RBs (Maroney, Morris Faulk) and Welker on the other side and he excelled again.

It ain't all about Moss.

[cookinbrak]

When did Randall Cunningham have Randy Moss for 11 years?

[Sandy Claws]

When did Randall Cunningham have Randy Moss for 11 years?

Take a second look. It's pretty clear he mislabeled the 2 columns.

[Snake]

All I can say is NE with out Moss= SB NE with Moss= No SB. You do the math.

[King Taharqa]

He's a Hall Of Fame WR EASY. Women lie, men lie, numbers dont lie.

[bigmanstew]

He had the skill set to be the best ever, but he didn't have the work ethic or the heart to do that.

[Seal (SmittyIsOurSavior)]

Tom Brady sure did suffer without Moss.

[Cat'sGrowl]

he is top 5 all time. up there with cris carter and terrell owens

Uhhhh....

[DaCityKats]

if not top 5, he is most def top 10. some of you guys hate is ridiculous.

[Pumpkin King]

BS

WHy didn't the author show the improvement in the Raiders' QBs while Moss was there? Maybe because there was none?

The reality is that he started with a team with a decent QB, a decent running game, and quality on the other end of the line (Minnesota with Cunningham, George, Culpepper as QBs, Smith as RB and HOFer CArter as WR). He went to Oakland where he had crap and performed like it, then landed in NE with Brady, a decent committe of RBs (Maroney, Morris Faulk) and Welker on the other side and he excelled again.

It ain't all about Moss.

Yeah, and when Moss left Minnesota, what happened to Culpepper?

You've got to be pretty ignorant to not think Moss is one of the best receivers to ever play the game. Seriously.

[cookinbrak]

Take a second look. It's pretty clear he mislabeled the 2 columns.

I checked Moss' stats...he mislabeled everything. Or just made it up.

7 years with Minn

2 years with OAK (not included)

3 years with NE

[OneBadassCat]

Steve Smith is the best ever.

[Sandy Claws]

Yeah, and when Moss left Minnesota, what happened to Culpepper?

You've got to be pretty ignorant to not think Moss is one of the best receivers to ever play the game. Seriously.

Not as ignorant as somebody who chooses to put words in anothers mouth. Nowhere in my post do I say he isn't "one of the best to ever play". I only pointed out that he had advantages. There's no way to say that other WRs wouldn't have produced in those same situations.