Jump to content
  • Welcome!

    Register and log in easily with Twitter or Google accounts!

    Or simply create a new Huddle account. 

    Members receive fewer ads , access our dark theme, and the ability to join the discussion!

     

Rank the all-time Panther QBs


Recommended Posts

They are, drum roll...

Frank Reich

Kerry Collins

Jack Trudeau

Steve Beuerlein

Steve Bono

Jeff Lewis

Dameyune Craig

Chris Weinke

Jim Harbaugh

Matt Lytle

Rodney Peete

Randy Fasani

Jake Delhomme

Stefan LeFors

Brett Basanez

JT O'Sullivan

David Carr

Matt Moore

Vinny Testaverde

Josh McCown

Hunter Cantwell

AJ Feeley

Jimmy Clausen

Tony Pike

Damn, we haven't had much of which to speak.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Jake should be #1. Yes he had a bad last season, but he did the most for this franchise. Only time we ever went to the Super Bowl was with Jake. I can't believe some people seem to hate the guy after what he did for this team.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm going by what I've seen on the field.

So I'm assuming you didn't watch from 2003-2008, especially '04, '05, and '07? Matt Moore has been good in limited playing time, but there's no way to compare a QB that's 6-2 to one that's 53-37 with Carolina and was one of the better playoff QBs in NFL history until the Arizona fiasco.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

So I'm assuming you didn't watch from 2003-2008, especially '04, '05, and '07? Matt Moore has been good in limited playing time, but there's no way to compare a QB that's 6-2 to one that's 53-37 with Carolina and was one of the better playoff QBs in NFL history until the Arizona fiasco.

I'm just judging by the way they play. Moore's mechanics are far superior and he plays smarter than Jake. Jake was good when he still had his accuracy and he had a mojo/magic about him. And Jake was on top of his game in 03/04. He had to be otherwise he was going to get cut, he was a backup and an NFL Europe player. Then Steve Smith became god and Jake got complacent.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Jake should be #1. Yes he had a bad last season, but he did the most for this franchise. Only time we ever went to the Super Bowl was with Jake. I can't believe some people seem to hate the guy after what he did for this team.

Beuerlein beats Jake in every major passing category while Jake has had better talent around him. Don't confuse reality with hate.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

So I'm assuming you didn't watch from 2003-2008, especially '04, '05, and '07? Matt Moore has been good in limited playing time, but there's no way to compare a QB that's 6-2 to one that's 53-37 with Carolina and was one of the better playoff QBs in NFL history until the Arizona fiasco.

Yeah Jake was pretty good 03-05. But 06 was when he was starting to go downhill.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


  • PMH4OWPW7JD2TDGWZKTOYL2T3E.jpg

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • That new home page looking sexy and thicc
    • Serious question:  Why LG and not RG?  There may be something I do not know, but Hunt's contract is huge and he could be let go after this season (post june 1 cut) and it would save the Panthers a ton of money.  Extending him would be paying a G who is in his mid 30s guaranteed money (and I do not see that as a terrible thing).  So if we release him at age 31, we save $19m.  I like him, but at 31, will he be worth the mega contract?   LG Damien Lewis has actually outperformed Hunt and he is a year younger.  He would also save less vs. the cap and leave less in the dead cap pool.  While his current contract expires after the 2027 season, he is a better prospect (IMO) to extend because only 50% of his current contract was guaranteed.  Here are his contract numbers.   Now, getting to Ickey--he could want LT money if he is offered a second contract.  If we pay him LT money to play either G positions, we are likely overpaying.  Secondly, the injury he suffered could be one that limits his productivity.  Ickey was improving, but he was an average LT.  The only way I re-sign Ickey is to have him accept a G contract and make a lot of it incentive based.     I feel like I am missing something, but in my mind, Ickey was always a guard if you consider the fact that he is an average OT and would be a great G.  Is that still the case (injury)?
×
×
  • Create New...