Cam Newton Workout Phenomenal

[C47]

Here's what I can put together on what Scouts Inc thought:

1) Larry Fitz

2) Gallery

3) Sean Taylor

4) Big Ben

5) Eli

6) Roy Williams

7) Kellen Winslow

8) Deangelo Hall

Then Rivers at 12

So you still have three QBs in the top 12. That's far from a week class....

[mav1234]

I don't think it was a weak QB class.

It also had Schaub in it :P

[C47]

I don't think it was a weak QB class.

It also had Schaub in it :P

Yea, that's one of the stronger QB classes in recent memory....

[mav1234]

http://walterfootball.com/draft2004.php walters was nearly right on.

scouts inc may have done their grades very early in the process or something, too.

[C47]

http://walterfootball.com/draft2004.php walters was nearly right on.

scouts inc may have done their grades very early in the process or something, too.

Yea walter is the one I look at the most. How nice it is to get this thread away from race....

[C47]

Talk about a weak class....the 2005 class produced Aaron Rogers, Alex Smith, Kyle Orton and Derek Anderson.....:lol:

[mav1234]

I would be curious to track what certain experts thought of the depth of classes through time and the results from them.

[teeray]

Yea' date=' that's one of the stronger QB classes in recent memory....[/quote']

It really was a strong QB class!! But many didn't consider it as strong at the time because there were a lot of unknowns with the top QB's in that class.

Let me also be clear that I don't think this class will be that strong there are only two QB's I really like and one I kinda like. But there wasn't a consensus number one QBk. All the QB's had significant questions (granted I had no idea Ben was rated so high so it defeats my initial argument a little bit). And I think it reflects a little bit what we have in this draft.

[C47]

I would be curious to track what certain experts thought of the depth of classes through time and the results from them.

Yea, I would be interested in reading that as well....

[teeray]

By the way, the 2004 draft was pretty strong in general. Larry Fitzgerald, Kellen Winslow, D-Will, Sean Taylor and three big time QB's. Pretty strong top half of that draft!!

[C47]

Haha 2003 was even worse. Carson Palmer, Byron Leftwich, Kyle Boller and Rex Grossman all taken in the first. Granted Carson was awesome till his leg got shredded but still.....

Best QB from the class UDFA Tony Romo....

[C47]

By the way, the 2004 draft was pretty strong in general. Larry Fitzgerald, Kellen Winslow, D-Will, Sean Taylor and three big time QB's. Pretty strong top half of that draft!!

Dunta Robinson, Vince Wilfork, Tommie Harris, Johnathan Vilma, Chris Gamble, Miachael Jenkins and Steven Jackson were all first rounders as well. I'm assuming you meant DeAngelo Hall when you said D-Will.....

[teeray]

Yes sorry. Freudian slip

[teeray]

Let's get this thread back on track. So who is racist? :)