Newton starter vs Bengals, Week 1 starter TBD

[CRA]

You can evaluate them on what you saw, unless you don't think you are knowledgeable to to take everything into consideration and evaluate their play.

I can but it is a flawed scenario.

I can watch Man A fight a homeless man

I can watch Man B fight a trained MMA fighter

No point in claiming Man A looked better.....meaningless. Unless you have been pimping Man A and knocking Man B....and it supports your stance.

[koolkatluke]

Matt Moore played better than Cam. But in the end, playing better doesn't mean you are a better QB.

Cam didnt play bad just not as good as Moore.

Alex Smith looked better then Vick we all know who the better QB is.

[micnificent28]

How many failed third down or stalled drives = one turnover?

Moore also gave his team a chance at a TD, Cam barely crossed the 50

Lots of things to consider...

Only the true Cam apologists think it's even close.

If would haves and wishes had some value we'd all be rich. Yes moore moved the ball better but he Turned the ball over and gave up points to a dormant offense otherwise. That turnover erases all the good he might have done and put them right back at 0. Yes he would have threw a td but it didnt happen. I'm not giving him credit for that.

[CRA]

Alex Smith looked better then Vick we all know who the better QB is.

Cam played significantly better than Vick....who has already been penciled in to lead his team to a Superbowl.

preseason game 2....is just that. preseason game 2.

[koolkatluke]

TRD should be mad at Carolina 1st team Def. They made it so Moore won't be the starter in Miami either.

[mav1234]

haha, man we made Henne look like Joe Montana.

[rodeo]

Jesus fuging Christ this is not the TRD forum, stop replying to him. This poo is getting ridiculous.

[koolkatluke]

Cam played significantly better than Vick....who has already been penciled in to lead his team to a Superbowl.

preseason game 2....is just that. preseason game 2.

I agree not to mention the fact Cam had Bad starting field position and less chances due to Miami going up and down the field on our Def.

[TheRealDeal]

Aren't you doing a 180 from last week? You didn't give credit for Cam throwing good passes at Lafell in the end zone or the drops by Edwards and Clowny. Now you want to bring up drops?

I gave Cam plenty of credit for the great ball he threw that Armanti dropped. I said it was the best pass he's ever thrown and gave me hope for the future if he could make that more consistent. I also said Clowney was neutral to me because the ball could have been a tad behind him allowing the defender to make a play but it also could have been a drop.

I also said the first pass to LaFell in the endzone was a good ball but was the victim of PI/good defense.

The second ball was on the ground so he doesn't deserve anything for that.

Maybe you should read my posts instead of assuming what they say. I doubt you lack the reading comprehension necessary to understand them though.

If would haves and wishes had some value we'd all be rich. Yes moore moved the ball better but he Turned fhe ball over and gave up points to a dormant offense otherwise. That turnover erases all the good he might have done and put them right back at 0. Yes he would have threw a td but it didnt happen. I'm not giving him credit for that.

So you are saying that good throws that are incompletions don't count? I need to reevaluate Cam's first game then.

I gave him credit for his great throw that Armanti dropped yet you acknowledge that you won't give Moore credit for a good throw that would have resulted in a TD and I'm the biased one...

[beastson]

Jesus fuging Christ this is not the TRD forum, stop replying to him. This poo is getting ridiculous.

Lol see a Cam thread with hella responses you already know what's going on

[koolkatluke]

haha, man we made Henne look like Joe Montana.

I would say more Elway with the running out the pocket poo he was doing getting big chunks of yards with his feet.

[TheRealDeal]

TRD should be mad at Carolina 1st team Def. They made it so Moore won't be the starter in Miami either.

If we would have had a starting caliber DT in there we would have been able to stop Miami running all over us AND we would have a starting caliber QB.

Thanks Hurney.

[mav1234]

he just showed up actually, we were going back and forth for a bit without him

[footballisasport]

Oh okay

The only reason Cam has less than a 50% completion percentage, constantly throws off his back foot, is scared of a blitz, and can't lead the team down the field is that I'm a hater.

Got it.

With all those so called mistakes you noticed, did u noticed that Cam still never made a fumble and gave the opposing team a free gift like Matt Moore did? But I guess that's no biggie cause it's just a PRESEASON GAME...It would only a biggie if Cam did it.

It's good to see u're paying way more attention to Cam's game. Need to feel justified in ur heart that the Panther's did the wrong thing by getting rid of Matt Moore. We all know how that psychology works. But didn't Matt not lose his starting job to Jimmy? Do u hate Jimmy also?

Also, sad to see that Matt Moore couldn't win the starting job from a QB who had to hear chants of Kyle Orton from the team fans during his TC.