Players you completely whiffed on

[Swarly]

Sparked by a post in the Panthers forum. Time to eat some crow.

Cam Newton - didn't want him, looks to be a future star

Matt Moore - thought he would be the next great undrafted QB

Dwayne Jarrett - thought he would be a perennial pro bowler

Aaron Curry - thought he would be a star, safest pick in the draft, etc

Golden Tate - proclaimed him the next Steve Smith

Mardy Gilyard - thought he would do great things

[GritsRgreat]

Renaldo Turnbull!! I thought he would beast it up when Carolina signed him. But hey, i was young in those days.

[Keith Moons Liver]

not a player but ron rivera

i had really high hopes for him

[Swarly]

not a player but ron rivera

i had really high hopes for him

too soon for Rivera. he's made some dumbass calls but so has Harbaugh.

[Falcons1stPanthers2nd]

Wanted Glenn Dorsey lol.

[JawnyBlaze]

I also thought MM would be the next great undrafted QB

Thought the same as OP on G. Tate

Didn't think Jarrett would be a perennial Pro Bowler, but I thought he'd be a good solid #2 to take over for Moose.

Thought EB would be the next Freeney (even bought his jersey ugh)

Thought Naanee woul be a great addition, at least a good #3

[Swarly]

I also thought MM would be the next great undrafted QB

Thought the same as OP on G. Tate

Didn't think Jarrett would be a perennial Pro Bowler, but I thought he'd be a good solid #2 to take over for Moose.

Thought EB would be the next Freeney (even bought his jersey ugh)

Thought Naanee woul be a great addition, at least a good #3

I literally broke my TV remote when I heard Clausen's name announced because I wanted Tate sooooo bad. I mean he's shown flashes of being a play maker but not what I expect of him.

I also thought Sam Bradford would get sacked into a coma his rookie year and be a constant injury magnet his entire career. Proved out to be tougher than I thought.

[R0CKnR0LLA]

my take on gilyard before the draft

I know alot of people are high on Gilyard but he reminds me too much of Drew Carter. Great straight line speed but poor at route running and getting separation.

[R0CKnR0LLA]

Duke Robinson, loved the pick

thought he had a chance to be a day 1 starter but definitely by year two he's starting and a stud at that

f**k me

[Swarly]

Duke Robinson, loved the pick

thought he had a chance to be a day 1 starter but definitely by year two he's starting and a stud at that

f**k me

thought Duke would be alright but figured he dropped for a reason

I'll one up you on that though.

Thought Bernadeau would be a stud.

[setzer2030]

I was stoked on Eric Shelton (pick 54) in 2005. Now looking back on it I would do anything to have Vincent Jackson (pick 61) instead. 2007 I loved the Jarrett and Ryne Robinson picks.

[X-Clown]

I was cussing when we picked some linebacker named Jon beason

[tarheelpride]

I was cussing when we picked some linebacker named Jon beason

This. I wasn't too happy when Willis went off the board. Glad I got proved wrong.

Joey Harrington (wanted him #2 when we got Pep)

Drew Carter

Matt Moore

Thomas Davis (when healthy). I wanted Derrick Johnson more.

[Nicbsbll2]

I hated the Thomas Davis pick.

I hated the Jon Beason pick.

I hated the Jonathon Stewart pick.

I hated the Jimmy Clausen pick.

Well, I guess I got one right...