Top Ten All-Time Panthers

[SamTheRam]

So the NFL Network had a Top 10 All Time Cowboys yesterday and Steelers today. What would your top 10 All time Panthers be? I'd say...

10. Jake Delhomme

9. Dan Morgan

8. DeAngelo Williams

7. Jordan Gross

6. Michael Bates

5. Muhsin Muhammad

4. Julius Peppers

3. Wesley Walls

2. John Kasay

1. Steve Smith

[Russian Bear]

Kickers are not real players. I would take Bates out of the top 10 and put in Beuerlein. Mike Minter should probabbly be in there as well. Eric Davis as well?

[Tarheels23]

I'm not a Jake fan, but I would at lease put him in the Top 5. Also I loved what Morgan has done, but I would replace him with Brad Hoover.

[Russian Bear]

Forgot about Lamar Lathon and Kevin Greene. Hoover should not be in the top ten for sure.

[KillerKat]

No Mills? Wtf? He's half of the reason why we now got "keep pounding" on our jerseys.

I think it would be like this (trying to incorporate what the organization or ESPN would think more than me)

1. Sam Mills

2. John Kasay

3. Steve Smith

4. Julius Peppers

5. Jake Delhomme

6. Muhsin Muhammad

7. Wesley Walls

8. Kevin Greene

9. Mike Minter

10. Jon Beason

[Leeroy Jenkins PhD]

I would have to include Stephen Davis on my all time top 10. The man was a work horse

[KendrickPanther]

Steve Smith

Sam Mills

John Kasay

Moose

Dan Morgan

Jordan Gross

Jake Delhomme

Wesley Walls

Mike Minter

Ricky Manning JR (this guy gets in basically for two playoff games)

[nctarheel0619]

You talking about career with the Panthers correct?

[Lilsmitty09]

10 years from now:

CAAAAAM

[Gallagher]

1. Steve Smith

2. John Kasay

3. Jake Delhomme

4. Julius Peppers

5. Mushin Muhammed

6. Mike Rucker

7. DeAngelo Williams

8. Mike Minter

9. Chris Gamble

10. Brad Hoover

Honorable mention: Jordan Gross, Jon Beason

[SamTheRam]

Sam Mills only played three years in Carolina, and they were the last three of his career. Definitely a top 10 Saint. Morgan had much more impact over his career, injury plagued as it was. Hoover and Minter were glue guys but never made a Pro Bowl. Rucker made one. Jenkins was the best in the biz for a year or two but then got hurt. As you might expect with a franchise that is 17 years old, there isn't a lot to choose from. Kasay had as big a part as anyone in getting the Panthers to the Super Bowl.

[KendrickPanther]

Loyalty and intangibles factored in for me. Peppers was a pain in the ass even though his production was good.

[KillerKat]

Sam Mills only played three years in Carolina, and they were the last three of his career. Definitely a top 10 Saint. Morgan had much more impact over his career, injury plagued as it was. Hoover and Minter were glue guys but never made a Pro Bowl. Rucker made one. Jenkins was the best in the biz for a year or two but then got hurt. As you might expect with a franchise that is 17 years old, there isn't a lot to choose from. Kasay had as big a part as anyone in getting the Panthers to the Super Bowl.

Mills is still the #1 Panther. He's the only player we have a statue of btw.

[jtnc]

Mills is still the #1 Panther. He's the only player we have a statue of btw.

Probably because Steve Smith nor Kasay have retired yet.