Why Clausen and Edwards are Panthers

[megadeth078]

Edwards is a converted QB who has never made a NFL catch....he is as noob as anyone.

Nope. He's still less noob, hence the spot on the roster.

[KillerKat]

AE and Clausen are the prime examples of why we will not get over the hump as long as Hurney is GM

[Simple and Plain]

Name a team with a 3rd string QB that doesn't fit the offense has no potential to develop into a player to run their offense?

I am all about 3 QBs. I am about 4 counting practice squad. A warm body isn't a reason though....

I am not up to speed on 3rd string QBs nor am I about to go look at them. Because in the big scheme of things it is not a big deal.

DA fits our scheme as well as Jimmy, DA is just better.

[koolkatluke]

Because Hurney still can't admit the mistakes he makes.

[CRA]

The reason they are on the team is because individuals FAR smarter than anyone here thinks they should be. Period. No one here would ever even remotely have a chance to be a GM or HC. Everything this FO does is right compared to the viewpoints on this sitre because those individuals making the decesions are better than any one here. Not a hard concept to grasp.

You so realize people do dumb poo in all walks of life? NFL isn't immune to that.

Mitt Romney isn't immune to painfully dumb poo bc he is going to run for President. He can't pull the everything I do card is right and you can't argue otherwise....if you were right then you would be the Republican nominee. Silly.

Marty Hurney knows a lot more about football than me. Fact. That doesn't mean Marty can't do wrong and it be seen by others with less overall knowledge.

[FirstRoundPick]

Nope. He's still less noob. Hence, the spot on the roster.

Our GM can't possibly make a mistake!

[CRA]

I am not up to speed on 3rd string QBs nor am I about to go look at them. Because in the big scheme of things it is not a big deal.

DA fits our scheme as well as Jimmy, DA is just better.

DA fits the scheme. Jimmy doesn't.

Jimmy is just here bc Hurney drafted him. Wasn't drafted for this scheme. Weak armed

QBs who can't play in the pocket DON'T fit the scheme. How doesn't Jimmy fit a vertical passing offense?

[megadeth078]

Our GM can't possibly make a mistake!

I don't understand why you guys think the other receivers were more worthy. Potential doesn't mean poo at this point of the offseason with the start of the season coming up. You have to go with the player that could actually be useful on gameday, the player that actually has experience with this offense. If the players cut are young enough to make it onto the PS, then stash them there. If somebody steals them from us, then oh well, they're worthless right now anyways. These other receivers may have more upside, but they're not going to be worth anything this season if they don't know anything about the game or this offense. You don't keep players on the roster that can help us win games 2 seasons from now. Either way, you're still picking through trash. Does it really matter which trash he kept?

[fieryprophet]

Look you stupid motherfugers, if AE and Clausen are still on the team, that has more to do with Rivera than it does Hurney. I say this a million times, but Hurney does not make personnel decisions by himself.

[FirstRoundPick]

Look you stupid motherfugers, if AE and Clausen are still on the team, that has more to do with Rivera than it does Hurney. I say this a million times, but Hurney does not make personnel decisions by himself.

Fine. We need a GM that does his job.. evaluate talent, and a coach that does his job...coach the talent. Apparently, we have too much of a load on Rivera, if he evaluates Clausen and Edwards as talented.

[Simple and Plain]

DA fits the scheme. Jimmy doesn't.

Jimmy is just here bc Hurney drafted him. Wasn't drafted for this scheme. Weak armed

QBs who can't play in the pocket DON'T fit the scheme. How doesn't Jimmy fit a vertical passing offense?

DA doesn't fit a lot of what our team has become now because of Cam. If we really were concerned about this we should have cut DA too and get a mobile #2 to really fit our scheme... especially because #2 is about ten times more important than #3.

[CRA]

Look you stupid motherfugers, if AE and Clausen are still on the team, that has more to do with Rivera than it does Hurney. I say this a million times, but Hurney does not make personnel decisions by himself.

Hurney makes the ultimate decision.

And Rivera or Fox...common theme remains the organIzation hangs onto unproductive drafted players longer than other teams.

[tiger7_88]

True. But it is easy to name a franchise that has parted with a draft pick early on....so it isn't rare that you can go through every team and name

a mistake they admitted to.....just not Carolina

What you say is also true.

But of all those that are kept? Many are often not particularly deserving of it because?

Because they were a high-round (1, 2, or 3) draft pick.

[FirstRoundPick]

DA doesn't fit a lot of what our team has become now because of Cam. If we really were concerned about this we should have cut DA too and get a mobile #2 to really fit our scheme... especially because #2 is about ten times more important than #3.

Yeah, because you need a mobile QB to throw down the field. DA has proven himself within this scheme. Here and in Cleveland.