judging Cam by wins/losses & playoff success

[Guest manure muncher]

Quarterbacks who won a playoff game as a rookie or second year player:

The Golden Calf of Bristol

Mark Sanchez

Russell Wilson

Colin Kaepernick

Quarterbacks who failed to win a playoff game as a rookie or second year player:

Joe Montana

John Elway

Peyton Manning

Brett Favre

Eli Manning

Cam Newton

[cultclassiccat]

2nd

[L-TownCat]

I'm not at my computer right now but I swear to you sir that in the morning I will pie and rep you till you can barely walk. I can not ditto this post any harder.

[Lumps]

shoot me in the fuging face

[Ken]

is dumb

[Rubi]

Solid points. I approve.

Cam paved the road for RG3 with his electric rookie year.

Redskins traded a king's ransom for RG3. Played him while he was hurt. Now his knee has been totaly reconstructed. Probably wont be the last time he has issues with it

We are so lucky to have a talented quarterback who is built like a tank. A record setting tank

[TheRed]

Hmm, manure muncher... Seriously? I don't know what to make of this thread.

[chef17]

What is the point of this thread?

[The NFL Shield At Midfield]

what happened to that huge wall of text you originally wrote. that was good.

[Lumps]

you guys are lucky you saw it after the edits

i'm seriously going to take a break from this poo, christ

[Kevin Greene]

One would surmise a prerequisite of winning a Playoff game in your first year would be to make the Playoffs.

[L-TownCat]

Yeah what happened to the brilliance that was beneath those unimportant comparisons. You removed all that was pieable.

[Lumps]

just let it go man let it go...let this thread sink and die...the idiocy hurts

obviously a troll...1 post?

come on guys

[carolina-chuck]

Why is Wilson name with Kaep? He's a rookie; should be with The Golden Calf of Bristol and Sanchez if thats how you're categorizing your group.

Add Luck and RGIII to the list of rookies who failed to win a playoffs game.