Jon Snow

That's not what I'm gathering from this board. What I'm hearing is that if the team doesn't trade everything for Young or Stroud they aren't "taking a shot" at a young qb and are therefore doomed to mediocrity.

The Panthers are signing a qb in FA. You might as well prepare yourself for that. The only thing left to figure out is whether they are bluffing about going all in for one of these rookie prospects.

I'm saying that if the Panthers do not trade the farm to get the #1 pick or trade up for any of the top 4 picks but rather take someone else at 9 for qb or a qb later in the draft would it still be considered "taking a shot" on an unknown rookie?

You don't try to trade until draft day. And again, is it only classified as "taking a shot" if it's for your preferred qb and not someone else?

I think Dugan and Bennett go higher than most think.

You can add USC to that list as well.

I agree with you in most respects but I would not fixate on OSU qb's. But that's just me.

Of course they will. We would get raped. There's not a qb is this draft worth getting raped over.

I never suggested they would pass on him at 9. I suggested that they may not be willing to trade up for him. I seriously doubt they pass on any of the so called top 3 at 9.

Now he's the passing game coordinator. He's not calling plays anymore obviously.

How do you know that the staff feel the same way about Stroud as you do? From every ranking I've taken the time to look at has the qbs ranked like this. 1. Young 13 thru 15 Stroud, Levis, AR. Or. 3. Young 13-14. Stroud, Levis 25-28. AR

So he's getting a promotion. Who was his understudy?

What I gather is that the shot everyone is speaking of is a shot on their preferred qb. If it's not their preferred guy then it's not considered taking a shot?

I have no say in the matter so I will have to roll with whoever they bring in. Whether it's thru the draft, FA or both. How do you like me now?

He got clicks that's all he's after. If you stop reading his garbage it will not matter what he says.

One does not preclude the other.

Not necessarily. Say for instance they do something crazy like go defense again at 9. What's to prevent them from moving back into the bottom of the 1st for a qb? Hell they could even trade back into the 15 to 20 range if they just have to have a qb. There's more than one way to skin this cat.

Well there's a small chance they manage to do both. There are some good qb prospects in this draft but they are just not hyped up like the 3 you only here about. So I would not assume they cannot do both.

Now let's not go that far. He's BEEN better than anyone here since Cam, yes. But if he's signed here let's see what he does HERE before we crown his ass mmkay.

Honestly, I didn't have one at first. As it went on I thought Reich was probably the best of the bunch from an experience perspective. But I didn't sit in on the interviews with the other's so I was open there for awhile. I'm comfortable with how it played out so far.

I had forgotten about Reich's interest in him when he was with the Colts. I doubt that's changed much since then. It is certainly something to watch.

Not if Payton is involved in it. I would not trust that sombitch at all.

I think the Panthers go after him eventually.

I just made the contract length bit up. The second part is true.