Underrated/Overrated

[Mol3m4n]

Which NFL players are the most overrated or underrated?

Overrated: Matt Ryan is my first choice. People claim he is on the verge of being elite, but wouldn't most quarterbacks be almost elite with two #1 WR's and a #2 playing slot?

Underrated: Matt Forte is on the top of my list because of his constant production. Yet he doesn't get any media attention that he deserves.

Sent from my SCH-R970 using CarolinaHuddle mobile app

[WhoAmI?]

Overrated: Andrew Luck. According to everybody, he is the Golden Boy that can do no wrong, but he has yet to anything that Cam hasn't done. Cam actually had better numbers in his first 2 years than Luck had, yet they say Cam is a tier 3 QB while Luck is a top 5.

 

Underrated: Earl Thomas. All the spotlight goes to Sherman, but it is really Thomas who strikes fear and controls that secondary. It seems that everybody always leaves out Thomas when talking about the Hawks.

 

[The Huddler]

Russell Wilson. Does nothing special and rides his stacked team.

[Mol3m4n]

Overrated: Andrew Luck. According to everybody, he is the Golden Boy that can do no wrong, but he has yet to anything that Cam hasn't done. Cam actually had better numbers in his first 2 years than Luck had, yet they say Cam is a tier 3 QB while Luck is a top 5.

Underrated: Earl Thomas. All the spotlight goes to Sherman, but it is really Thomas who strikes fear and controls that secondary. It seems that everybody always leaves out Thomas when talking about the Hawks.

I was thinking of putting Thomas, but he seems to get his due respect. All of the people watching know he's the best in the Seahawks secondary except for parts of the media. They just want to ride the Sherman Rant hype all the way to the bank.

Sent from my SCH-R970 using CarolinaHuddle mobile app

[Monday Night Shyamalan]

Overrated: RG Knee.

 

Underrated: THOMAS DAVIS

[xerxes]

Russell Wilson. Does nothing special and rides his stacked team.

I just can't agree with this after his game against us. Against Matty Ice we would have had 10 sacks that game, but Wilson managed to get free and find open guys.

[TNPanther]

Overrated: Colin Kaepershit. Is a one read quarterback riding his stacked team as well.

Underrated: Phillip Rivers. I feel like the guy never gets talked about.

[PantherWake]

Overrated: Luck. He's not the second coming or a Tier 1 QB.

 

Underrated: Thomas Davis/Earl Thomas is tie. Great players that are sometimes overshadowed by a bigger player on the team.

 

 

[Stroupe-a-loop]

Just on our own team, I think that Luke Kuechly and Thomas Davis were virtually the same caliber of player this past season, but Luke gets a little too much run from the national media and Davis gets none. Kind of dumb.

[Icege]

Overrated: Kaepernick
Underrated: TD

[0115]

Overrated: RG Knee.

 

Underrated: THOMAS DAVIS' KNEE***

 

Fixxed for ya. TD was already a badass

[CelticCat]

Overrated - Julius Thomas, a Manning product.

 

Underrated - Greg Olsen, quietly getting it done in Carolina.

 

 

[TheRumGone]

Russell Wilson. Does nothing special and rides his stacked team.

 

this is bullshit

 

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q7II7HKusrg

 

he makes the same kind of plays Cam does. he's actually incredible to watch.

 

 

as for overrated/underated:

 

overrated: luck (this is only because of media hype, dude can ball out but they have anointed him wayyyyyyyy too early)

 

underrated: TD (dude gets almost zero attention) but for non panther big ben.

[Boxhead85]

Overrated: Kaepernick (also Eric Decker <-- Manning product). This season should solidify where his career is going. They gave him weapons. Cam was able to put up numbers with an aging Smitty.

 

Underrated: Earl Thomas