Thank you David Glenn for your take on 89

[top dawg]

From the original discussion...

 

 

Not that I expect that'll change anything given that your last several posts have essentially come down to "It doesn't matter what actually happened or what anybody says. Steve Smith is still right."

 

I listened to the interview. It wasn't as concrete as you purported it to be. Voth's opinion came out loud and clear amid some general points about what transpired during the season and after G-man had already axed Smith afterwards.  I never said Smith was totally "right" about everything he did. I never said he was an angel. What I did say is that he should have been notified during his exit interview (or soon thereafter) that he was going to be cut.  He wasn't. That's essentially what I said regardless of how you're trying to erroneously frame it.

 

You obviously feel that it was "right" for G-man and Rivera to handle Smitty's firing the way that it actually happened, notwithstanding what anybody says (except for Bill Voth I suppose), and that's your opinion.  It's disappointing to me as a Panthers fan that you would take that position, but it is what it is.

[Mr. Scot]

I listened to the interview. It wasn't as concrete as you purported it to be. Voth's opinion came out loud and clear amid some general points about what transpired during the season and after G-man had already axed Smith afterwards. I never said Smith was totally "right" about everything he did. I never said he was an angel. What I did say is that he should have been notified during his exit interview (or soon thereafter) that he was going to be cut. He wasn't. That's essentially what I said regardless of how you're trying to erroneously frame it.

You obviously feel that it was "right" for G-man and Rivera to handle Smitty's firing the way that it actually happened, notwithstanding what anybody says (except for Bill Voth I suppose), and that's your opinion. It's disappointing to me as a Panthers fan that you would take that position, but it is what it is.

I'm not letting hero worship alter my opinion of how a 35 year old professional should behave (i.e. not like a spoiled brat)

[SOJA]

If anyone doubts what Bill Voth says at this point you have not been watching this team at all for the past year

[TheRumGone]

If anyone doubts what Bill Voth says at this point you have not been watching this team at all for the past year

Pretty much. Dude has been on point