Max Hall the next Drew Brees???

[Dpantherman]

prob not. He'll either go in the 7th round, or end up undrafted. Hes only 6'0-6'1

Hes a tough kid. Who says we can't pick up more than 1 QB.

UPDATE: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O1AewMuz41g

didn't know about this. Forget everything I just said

[raleigh-panther]

That young man is impressive, isn't he.

Every time i watch BYU, and I watch them frequently, he just makes plays.

Although he isn't a big scrambler, for some reason, he reminds me of Steve Young, smart and makes those plays.

[Dpantherman]

For a guy his size I like him. Id be tempted to take a chance if hes still on the board late. After we draft a QB higher on the board

[CarolinaPanthers8789]

I have watched all of the Bowl Games so far and here who has impressed me.

Ryan Matthews- Running Back- Fresno State

Chastin West- Wide Receiver- Fresno State

A.J. Jefferson- Corner Back- Fresno State

Robert Malone- Punter- Fresno State

Max Hall- Quarterback- BYU

Dennis Pitta- Tight End- BYU

Manase Tonga- Full Back- BYU

[mrmiyagii]

I know I will get flamed for saying this but..

I actually wouldn't mind giving The Golden Calf of Bristol a chance

LULZ! *Flamesuit On*

[CarolinaPanthers8789]

I know I will get flamed for saying this but..

I actually wouldn't mind giving The Golden Calf of Bristol a chance

LULZ! *Flamesuit On*

I like him.

[raleigh-panther]

I like The Golden Calf of Bristol too. Big, tough guy (despite the crying and the flowers).

...a football player with a sensitive side (yikes).

What his arm can't do, his legs can; a little bit of Big Ben sans some personal controversy.

[Nytrogen]

So one bad game is enough to condem him?

[monstercat]

I don't think Hall has an NFL arm. He reminds me of the Texas Tech kid from last year...I can't even remember his name now and he didn't even make an NFL team as a FA, but he had monster numbers in college.

[ElkinPanthersFan]

If we were going that route, I'd rather have Armanti..

per http://www.journalnow.net/index.php/app_trail/entry/season-wrap-up-with-jerry-moore

Do you think Armanti Edwards will play in the NFL?

“I really do. I don’t remember the scout’s name, but he’s the one who did the workup on Drew Brees when he was at Purdue, and he says Armanti is just like him, that he’s the same size and everybody worried about the size (of Brees). I think the scouts now realize what a quick delivery Armanti has. He’s smart and he throws in the right places. He’s got a strong arm and I don’t think anybody is going to question his toughness. They’re more and more inclined to be in his corner right now, as a quarterback.”

[Cheetodude]

BYU quarterbacks do not make it in the NFL. Young & McMahon being exceptions.

Remember Detmer? Set all kinds of records at BYU, Heisman trophy winner...NFL bust.

A couple other BYU names to throw out there that did well at BYU but didn't do much in the League:

John Beck (still early, but the job at Miami was his to lose...he lost it)

Brandon Doman

John Walsh

Steve Sarkisian

Robbie Bosco

I'm skeptical of any quarterback coming out of BYU.

[raleigh-panther]

I think one could say that about a lot of schools.

I don't know that there is a 'QB U', unlike Penn State, "LB U'

[Saint J]

breesus will come again but not in the form of max hall